Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
298 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Statistics

West Virginia missing persons & unsolved case statistics

Numbers behind 1,074 missing person, death by force, unidentified, unclaimed, serial killer and mass murder cases in West Virginia – by state, decade, age, sex, race and how many are solved. Free to read and link to; members get every breakdown, filters, sortable tables and CSV downloads.

Data as of October 29, 2026 · updated daily · How these numbers are counted

Reset
Cases in West Virginia
1,074
968 open · 101 solved / resolved
Missing Persons
183
156 still missing · 14.8% located
Deaths by Force
788
716 unsolved · 8.9% solved
Unidentified Remains
32
28 unidentified · 12.5% identified
Unclaimed Persons
68
68 unclaimed · 0% claimed
Serial killer profiles
3
by the state where they killed
Added in the last 30 days
4
179 added or updated
Oldest open case
1783
Bartley Clay, Lake Shawnee, WV · unsolved

“Solved / resolved” means a missing person located, a death by force marked solved or charged, unidentified remains identified, or an unclaimed person claimed. Our homicide records focus on unsolved cases, so these shares are not police clearance rates – see the methodology.

Cases by type

Missing Persons 183 156 still missing
Deaths by Force 788 716 unsolved
Unidentified Remains 32 28 unidentified
Unclaimed Persons 68 68 unclaimed
Serial Killer Profiles 3

By state & province

Cases per state and per 100,000 residents, a shaded state-by-state list, top cities, and Indigenous missing and murdered (MMIP) by state.

Cases by state and province

Click a state or province to see its statistics. All case types.

CSV

Top cities by open cases

Missing, deaths by force, unidentified and unclaimed cases, by the city recorded on the case.

CSV
CityStateCasesOpenSolved / resolvedSolved / resolved %
CharlestonWV141130117.8%
HuntingtonWV1029387.9%
BeckleyWV383712.6%
MorgantownWV302826.7%
FairmontWV3026413.3%
ParkersburgWV252328%
ClarksburgWV2421312.5%
MartinsburgWV211929.5%
BluefieldWV1816211.1%
WheelingWV151500%
PrincetonWV151416.7%
FayettevilleWV119218.2%
SummersvilleWV9900%
DunbarWV9900%
South CharlestonWV9900%
Oak HillWV98111.1%
ElkinsWV117436.4%
ChapmanvilleWV87112.5%
WilliamsonWV7700%
WilliamsburgWV7700%
Charles TownWV7700%
WelchWV86225%
KingwoodWV76114.3%
Saint AlbansWV6500%
Bunker HillWV5500%
IaegerWV5500%
LoganWV5500%
Great CacaponWV5500%
Harpers FerryWV5500%
MiltonWV54120%
PhilippiWV54120%
MarlintonWV54120%
ElkviewWV54120%
RandWV54120%
DingessWV4400%
GraftonWV4400%
MoorefieldWV4400%
OceanaWV4400%
New CumberlandWV4400%
WeirtonWV73457.1%

By decade & year

Cases by decade and year, the solved share by decade (the “cold case curve”), and seasonality by month and day of the week.

Cases by decade

Stacked by case type.

CSV

Solved / resolved share by decade

The “cold case curve”: the share of each decade’s cases now marked solved, located, identified or claimed (decades with fewer than 10 cases are left out).

CSV

Cases by year (last 50 years)

Recent years include many newly added cases; older years are more likely to be resolved and removed from public databases.

CSV

Cases by month

Seasonality: month of the case date (only cases with a full date).

CSV

Cases by day of the week

Day of the week of the case date (only cases with a full date).

CSV

By age

Age groups for each case type, solved share by age, average ages and an age / sex pyramid.

Cases by age group

Average age: 37.2 missing · 37.2 deaths by force · 36.1 unidentified.

CSV

Solved / resolved share by age group

Share of each age group’s cases marked solved, located, identified or claimed.

CSV

Age and sex

Male (left) and female (right) by age group – missing, deaths by force, unidentified and unclaimed together.

CSV

By sex

Male / female split for each case type and solved share by sex.

Cases by sex

Share of each case type that is male, female or not recorded.

CSV

Solved / resolved share by sex

Share of male and female cases marked solved, located, identified or claimed.

CSV

By race & ethnicity

Race and ethnicity compared with the U.S. population, and the solved share for each group.

Cases by race / ethnicity

Share of each case type, compared with the U.S. population in the table.

CSV

Solved / resolved share by race / ethnicity

Share of each group’s cases marked solved, located, identified or claimed (groups with fewer than 10 cases are left out).

CSV

Solve rates & how long cases stay open

Case status for deaths by force, how many years open cases have been open, and a state-by-decade solved-share heatmap.

Deaths by force: case status

How each case is recorded. “Charged / in court” counts as solved in the solved share; accidental and self-inflicted deaths are left out of it.

CSV

How long open cases have been open

Years since the case date, for cases still unsolved, missing, unidentified or unclaimed.

CSV

Solved / resolved share by state and decade

Percent of missing, deaths by force, unidentified and unclaimed cases now solved, located, identified or claimed. Hover a cell for the count.

CSV
State1950s1960s1970s1980s1990s2000s2010s2020s
WV06305221
<2%2–55–1010–2020–3535–5050%+fewer than 10 cases

Rewards offered 7 deaths by force cases list a reward, and 6 of them are still unsolved.

Possible matches

Possible missing person / unidentified remains matches by score.

Possible missing person / unidentified matches

102,241 possible matches scoring 75% or higher, involving 13,698 missing persons and 7,876 unidentified remains. Browse the matches.

CSV

Serial killers & mass murders

Serial killers by victims and decade; mass murders by year, place, firearms, attacker and victims.

Serial killers by number of victims

Confirmed victims listed on each profile (3 profiles).

CSV

Serial killers by decade they started

CSV

Serial killers by sex and race

CSV
GroupProfilesShare
Sex: Male266.7%
Sex: Female133.3%
Race: Unknown / not recorded133.3%
Race: White266.7%

Longest-open cases

The oldest unsolved, missing, unidentified and unclaimed cases, linked to each case file.

Longest-open missing persons

The 25 oldest still missing cases in West Virginia.

CSV
NamePlaceDateYearsAgeSex
Betty Dolly SodderFayetteville, WVDec 1945815Female
Jennie Irene SodderFayetteville, WVDec 1945818Female
Louis Erico SodderFayetteville, WVDec 1945819Male
Martha Lee SodderFayetteville, WVDec 19458112Female
Maurice Antonio SodderFayetteville, WVDec 19458114Male
Lora SkaggsCharleston, WVJan 19487827Female
Seif MahssenWeirton, WVNov 1957690Male
James Lee HaynesWyoming County, WVDec 19636332Male
James BradyLogan, WVSep 19656135Male
Annita PriceMoundsville, WVMay 19745227Female
David BleaneyCharleston, WVAug 19755146Male
David Harry BleaneyCharleston, WVAug 19755146Male
Sheila PiercePoint Pleasant, WVJun 19784824Female
Susan RoopGauley, WVFeb 19794729Female
Mazie Sigmon-palmerCharleston, WVJul 19794724Female
Juanita ReedyBeckley, WVNov 19794736Female
Patricia VaughanMathias, WVMay 19824419Female
Alfred GibbonsChapmanville, WVSep 19824435Male
Mary OdellBelle/Quincy, WVOct 19824432Female
Bonnie HuttonNew Martinsville, WVFeb 19834344Female
Kathleen FarmerParkersburg, WVMar 19844238Female
Eddie FrasherHuntington, WVOct 19844242Male
Catherine McmillionSeneca Rocks, WVNov 19854158Female
Cathy HuffmanFranklin, WVNov 19854119Female
Ernest Stanley SlavikQuinwood, WVMay 19864056Male

Longest-open deaths by force

The 25 oldest unsolved cases in West Virginia.

CSV
NamePlaceDateYearsAgeSex
Bartley ClayLake Shawnee, WVAug 178324317Male
Sam PayneWelch, WVFeb 190012635Male
Robert Allen LillyElkins, WVJul 190112549Male
Owen C. RossHuntington, WVAug 190112525Male
John DillonDingess, WVDec 190112535Male
Page Campbell MarstillerElkins, WVApr 190212448Male
Francis Hays WilmothCoalton, WVJul 190212438Male
William FanningCoopers, WVAug 190212430Male
Salavia C. Lafe BowenWheeling, WVDec 190212439Male
Nehemiah DanielMontgomery, WVNov 190412256Male
Robert Henry CrockettBig Ugly, WVMay 190512135Male
Robert MurphyLogan, WVAug 190512158Male
James FranciscoBluefield, WVJun 190711945Male
Floyd LuskPineville, WVJan 190911725Male
Hallie Totten McCoyCass, WVApr 192410221Female
Herbert TottenCass, WVApr 192410219Male
Mrs William TottenCass, WVApr 192410245Female
Federal Prohibition Malcolm MalachiWelch, WVFeb 192510153Male
Federal William Frank PorterCamp Creek, WVJun 192510139Male
Jacob VandevanderCircleville, WVFeb 19517557Male
Bob Mack AgeeKingston, WVFeb 19626429Male
Ernest GwinnOak Hill, WVJul 19626476Male
Sammy SmithScarboro, WVOct 19626433Male
Mike RogersFayetteville, WVDec 19626418Male
Shirley Gene ArthurPineville, WVNov 19636333Female

Longest-open unidentified remains

The 25 oldest unidentified cases in West Virginia.

CSV
NamePlaceDateYearsAgeSex
Unidentified FemaleBath(Berkeley Spr…, WVMay 19507643Female
Unidentified MaleBeckley, WVJul 19725419Male
Unidentified MaleWVJul 19804631Male
Unidentified FemaleLittleton, WVFeb 19834338Female
Unidentified MaleWVFeb 19864048Male
Unidentified MaleNear Kearneysville, WVAug 19864024Male
Unidentified MaleNew Vrindiban, WVDec 19864025Male
Unidentified MaleWVJun 19883823Male
Unidentified MaleWellsburg, WVApr 19913555Male
Unidentified FemaleNear Cool Ridge…, WVSep 19913529Female
Unidentified FemaleNew Cumberland, WVApr 19943225Female
Unidentified MaleOak Hill, WVApr 19943240Male
Unidentified MaleLevels, WVSep 19972931Male
Unidentified MaleWVJul 20002648Male
Unidentified MaleSouth Charleston, WVJul 20032321Male
Unidentified MaleHenderson, WVApr 20071955Male
Unidentified MaleMorgantown, WVOct 20091735Male
Unidentified MaleNew Cumberland, WVFeb 20111560Male
Unidentified MaleMaxwelton, WVMar 20121445Male
Unidentified MalePrinceton, WVAug 20121414Male
Unidentified MaleLesage, WVJan 20131340Male
Unidentified MaleCharles Town, WVNov 20131347Male
Unidentified MaleWVApr 201610–Male
Unidentified MaleHarpers Ferry, WVApr 2017930Male
Unidentified MaleKenova, WVMay 2020639Male

Longest-open unclaimed persons

The 25 oldest unclaimed cases in West Virginia.

CSV
NamePlaceDateYearsAgeSex
Phillips CrowellWVMay 199927–Male
James CollinsWVJan 200620–Male
Roy JohnsonWVJan 200620–Male
David BoyceWVMar 200620–Male
Thomas JamesWVMay 200620–Male
Brett HanickWVJun 200620–Male
Allan WhismanWVJun 200620–Male
Craig WatkinsWVJul 200620–Male
Vernon WallerWVDec 200620–Male
Mary RunionWVJan 200719–Female
Harold HardyWVJan 200719–Male
Steve SusickWVNov 200719–Male
Eddie ThompsonWVDec 200719–Male
Vickie PowellHuntington, WVFeb 200818–Female
James WattsNewell, WVMay 200818–Male
Madison WiseClarksburg, WVMay 200818–Female
Errol BagnerMorgantown, WVJul 200818–Male
Nathan MartinCharleston, WVSep 200818–Male
Charles SpringfieldWheeling, WVOct 200818–Male
David McLeodWheeling, WVDec 200818–Male
Augustus JohnsonWVJan 200917–Male
Kenneth PayneCharleston, WVMar 200917–Male
Piotr JedrzejewskiHarpers Ferry, WVMar 200917–Male
Thomas CosbyMartinsburg, WVApr 200917–Male
Robert RichardsonSouth Charleston, WVMay 200917–Male

Community activity

Forum discussion, memorials, evidence boards and the most viewed cases.

Community activity

Real member activity on case pages (all cases, not affected by the filters).

CSV
MeasureCount
Cases with member forum discussion: Mass murders19
Cases with member forum discussion: Missing persons379
Cases with member forum discussion: Deaths by force717
Cases with member forum discussion: Serial killers59
Cases with member forum discussion: Unclaimed3
Cases with member forum discussion: Unidentified4
Cases with a MyMemorium memorial5,007
Evidence boards created by members256

Most viewed deaths by force cases

All-time page views.

CSV
CasePlaceViews
Joachim SummerfordAberdeen, NC12,682
Zion TerryRichmond, VA11,602
Travis A. HobbsNew-orleans, LA6,120
Shannon WatkinsJonesboro, GA5,496
Jameal GaudetHarvey, LA4,977
Melanie Lynn BerryWichita-falls, TX4,891
Kiarra Jazzmyn GeorgeSacramento, CA4,732
Romeca MeeksChicago, IL4,147
Shuaib Naz “Shuaiby” AslamStockton, CA3,767
Javon M. BaileyLouisville, KY3,737
Felicito CanalesBaton-rouge, LA3,591
Shawn HudsonThrockmorton County, TX3,563
Eric Tyrone Smith, Sr.Jackson, MS3,334
Benjamin Joseph DeenHattiesburg, MS3,296
David WashingtonPensacola, FL3,279

Methodology & how to cite

These statistics count the cases in the Crime Solvers Central database as of October 29, 2026. They are rebuilt every night.

What is counted

  • Missing persons – NamUs, NCMEC and Canadian police cases. “Located” means the case is marked resolved (found alive or deceased). Age is the age when last seen.
  • Deaths by force – homicides and other violent deaths from police, news, court and public records. “Solved” includes cases marked solved, charged / in court, primary suspect deceased or substantiated. Deaths ruled accidental or self-inflicted are counted but left out of solved shares.
  • Unidentified remains and unclaimed persons – NamUs cases. Unidentified ages use the middle of the medical examiner’s estimated range.
  • Serial killer profiles are placed in the state where they killed and the first year they were active; victims are the confirmed victims listed on the profile. Mass murders are incidents, dated by the attack; attacker and firearm details come from The Violence Project coding where available.
  • Race and ethnicity are as recorded by the source and grouped into broad categories; “Multiracial” is used when more than one is listed.
  • Per-100,000 rates use 2020 U.S. Census and 2021 Canadian Census populations.

Limits

  • This is not a complete count of all crime. Our homicide records lean heavily toward unsolved cases, so the solved share is much lower than official police clearance rates and should not be reported as one.
  • Coverage differs by state and by year: some cities and states have been imported in full, others only partly, and recent years include many newly added cases.
  • Cases without a date, age, state or race are left out of that breakdown only (they still count in the totals).

How to cite

Crime Solvers Central. “West Virginia Missing Persons & Unsolved Case Statistics.” Data as of October 29, 2026. https://crimesolverscentral.com/statistics/west-virginia

You’re welcome to link to this page or to any state’s page (for example /statistics/texas). Each chart’s Cite button copies a citation that links straight to that chart.