207 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.
Case Description
Any updates on this case?
Bonnie's daughter, Cindy Dort, was born in 1958 to Bonnie and her husband, David Gay. Cindy was taken from her parents at 3 and adopted by David's brother and wife. David divorced Bonnie, and while he was present in Cindy's life, she never met Bonnie. As an adult, she attempted to track Bonnie down. She found out that after the divorce, Bonnie remarried, moved to Colorado, and had a daughter called Tammy. Tammy is also missing; neither Bonnie nor Tammy have been seen since 1969. The family repor ...Read More
Last Seen: Feb 13, 1983
Last Seen: Feb 13, 1983
Links to Additional Sources (2)
See any mistakes?Victim Details
Nov 08, 2019
May 16, 2023
Bonnie
Hutton
85
44
67 inches
135 lbs
White / Caucasian
Female
Feb 13, 1983
New Martinsville
West Virginia
Wetzel County
No
386
66257
West Virginia State Police
Moundsville
West Virginia
Marshall County
26041
W.D. Henderson
Sergeant
1700 South Lafayette Avenue, West Virginia
3048434100
State
Law Enforcement
AF-278
West Virginia State Police
na
Red/Auburn
Blue
Blue
12/04/2025
Area Last Seen:
Forum Posts (3)
Hey everyone, I stumbled upon something odd while digging into the Bonnie Gay disappearance. Has any... ...Read More
08/19/2024
08/19/2024
I've been following Bonnie and Tammy's case, and I can't stop thinking about the discrepancy in the ... ...Read More
07/04/2024
07/04/2024
Has anyone else looked into the discrepancies in Bonnie Dort's reported disappearance dates? Accordi... ...Read More
04/07/2023
04/07/2023
