In the summer of 1978, as Providence Mayor Vincent "Buddy" Cianci campaigned for his second term, a trusted member of his staff was leading a quiet, unassuming life. John Leatherwood, a 32-year-old male aide in the mayor's office, was known by those who knew him as kind, polite, and a "sharp dresser." He worked as a Cultural Affairs Officer, a role that involved arranging fundraising events at city hall and organizing charitable donations by city employees. John lived with his mother, Adeline, at the Wake Robin Apartments in Lincoln, Rhode Island, and by all accounts, had no known enemies.
The night of Saturday, June 10, 1978, began like any other. Around 7:30 p.m., John left his home, not telling his mother where he was going. Later that evening, he was reportedly seen at a couple of bars in downtown Providence. What happened in the hours that followed remains a mystery that has haunted investigators for decades.
In the pre-dawn hours of Sunday, June 11, a Pawtucket patrolman on a routine check of Veteran's Memorial Park on Smithfield Avenue noticed a white Ford Mustang parked in a dirt lot. Two hours later, around 5:30 a.m., the officer, Joseph O'Donnell, returned to find the car still there. On the roof of the vehicle sat a pack of cigarettes and a pair of prescription sunglasses.
The officer's subsequent search of the park led to a gruesome discovery. Behind one of the stone barbecue fireplaces, a common spot for summer family gatherings, lay the body of John Leatherwood. He had been the victim of a vicious and frenzied attack, having been stabbed between 12 and 24 times, primarily in the abdomen. The scene was confounding for investigators; robbery was immediately ruled out as a motive. John's wallet, watch, jewelry, and car keys were all found on his person. This led police to believe the murder was personal and possibly a hate crime, a theory that persists to this day.
The Pawtucket Police Department launched an intensive investigation. In the hours after the discovery, detectives announced they had suspects, but no arrests were ever made. An early lead focused on a "knife-wielding madman" who had been committing home invasions in the area. This drifter was apprehended just 24 hours after John's body was found, in possession of a blood-saturated knife and clothing. However, forensic analysis at the University of Rhode Island's crime lab determined the blood type on the evidence was A positive, which did not match John's type B blood, eliminating the man as a suspect. The investigation stalled, leaving a void of answers for John's family and the community.
Over the years, John's case grew cold, but it was never forgotten. His murder is featured in a deck of cold case playing cards created by the Pawtucket Police Department to generate new leads; John is the king of diamonds. Detective Sue Cormier of the Pawtucket Police, who has worked to revive the case, has emphasized the deeply personal nature of the crime and the lingering questions. "We're not sure even why he was in Pawtucket that night," she stated in a 2019 interview. "What brought him here? Did he meet someone here? Did he just happen upon someone in that park?" The lack of a clear motive or connection to the location has been a major hurdle.
As of July 2025, the murder of John Leatherwood remains an active unsolved case. Investigators hope that with modern technology, evidence collected from the scene might yet yield DNA that could identify his killer. Detective Cormier has expressed hope that someone with information about John's life and his activities on that fateful night will finally come forward. "Just because the case is old and had you know stalled with some leads it doesn't mean we're giving up," she affirmed. The political turbulence of the Cianci era in Providence has passed, but the brutal end to a well-liked public servant's life in a quiet park continues to demand justice.
Anyone with information regarding the murder of John Leatherwood is urged to contact the Rhode Island Cold Case tip line at 1-877-RI-SOLVE.