Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Mary Jeter Mathis, a 36-year-old Black woman and mother of five, lived in a world of struggle that ultimately left her vulnerable to a predator. Known to frequent the Kensington area of Philadelphia, she was battling a drug addiction in the mid-1980s, a difficult time in a city that was also wrestling with poverty and a growing crack cocaine epidemic. Her life was cut short in 1987, making her one of seven women murdered by a man who would come to be known as "The Corpse Collector."

The end of Mary’s life was discovered in the sweltering heat of August 1987. For months, residents of the apartment building at 1324 North Eighth Street in North Philadelphia had complained about a foul odor coming from the third-floor apartment of a man named Harrison "Marty" Graham. On August 9, after the landlord finally evicted Graham for the unbearable stench, the true horror behind the smell was uncovered. When Graham fled, he nailed his door shut, but police were able to gain entry. Inside the squalid, trash-filled apartment, they made a series of gruesome discoveries.

Amid piles of garbage, soiled mattresses, and drug paraphernalia, investigators found human remains in various stages of decomposition. The first body discovered was a naked woman on a mattress. Soon after, another was found partially buried in trash. As the search continued, more remains were located: some skeletal, some wrapped in sheets, one stuffed in a closet, and another in a duffel bag on the roof. Mary’s body was among those found inside the apartment. An autopsy would later confirm she had been strangled to death. Investigators determined she had been killed within the last ten days prior to the discovery.

The Philadelphia Police Department launched an intense investigation and a city-wide manhunt for the 28-year-old Graham. He was seen in various parts of the city but managed to evade capture for a week. On August 17, 1987, Graham’s mother convinced him to surrender. He met her on a street corner about ten blocks from the apartment and she called the police. Graham was taken into custody without incident and soon confessed to the killings. He told detectives that he had lured the women, including Mary, to his apartment with the promise of drugs, engaged in sexual activity with them, and then strangled them.

Harrison Graham was charged with seven counts of murder and seven counts of abuse of a corpse. The victims were identified as Mary Jeter Mathis, Cynthia Brooks, Valerie Jamison, Barbara Mahoney, Robin DeShazor, Sandra Garvin, and Patricia Franklin. Many of the women, like Mary, were from marginalized communities, their struggles with addiction making them easy targets. Graham's longtime girlfriend, Robin DeShazor, was among the first he had killed, her death occurring sometime in late 1986.

In April 1988, Graham was convicted on all counts. The court handed down six death sentences and one life sentence. However, his death sentences were later commuted to life in prison without the possibility of parole after a Supreme Court ruling regarding the execution of intellectually disabled individuals; Graham had a tested IQ of 63. The case highlighted the extreme vulnerability of women battling addiction and poverty in the city's forgotten neighborhoods. Harrison Graham died in prison in 2003. Mary Mathis, a mother of five whose life ended in a house of horrors, is remembered as one of his seven victims, her case a tragic chapter in Philadelphia's history.

Links to Additional Sources (0)

See any mistakes? Let us know!