Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 4 sources
Do you know who murdered Teressa McCoy?
Teressa McCoy was a 27-year-old mother of two young children, remembered by those who knew her as a friendly and kind woman with a nice personality. Neighbors recalled her always waving, regardless of whether she knew the person. She had lived in her Louisville, Kentucky, neighborhood for a while before moving about a month prior to her death, and her loss left those who knew her imagining the difficult lives her children would face without their mother.

The day after Christmas 2017 became a day of tragedy. On the morning of December 27, the owner of Bessler Auto Parts on Strawberry Lane in south Louisville noticed a new Yukon SUV that seemed out of place in his lot. Inside, he made a grim discovery: Teressa McCoy, a white female, was in the passenger seat, still secured by her seatbelt, having been shot to death. Her death was quickly ruled a homicide by the Louisville Metro Police Department, marking the city's 107th of the year. The investigation immediately linked her murder to the disappearance of her friend, 27-year-old Austin Gamez.

Gamez, a father of two sons, had last been seen by his family on December 26. He and McCoy had plans to look at a house she was interested in buying that evening. It's believed that Gamez picked up McCoy in the rented SUV, and his mother's last contact with him was a text message at 5:04 p.m. Surveillance footage from the auto parts store showed the SUV being left in the parking lot around 7:00 p.m. the night of December 26, but the video was too dark to identify the driver. Gamez was nowhere to be found, and he has not been seen or heard from since.

The joint investigation into McCoy's murder and Gamez's disappearance led police to focus on a home on Ottawa Avenue. In December 2019, nearly two years after the crime, authorities made arrests. Larry Sauer, an acquaintance of Gamez, was charged with two counts of murder in connection with the deaths of both McCoy and Gamez, as well as tampering with evidence and drug trafficking. Police alleged that the murders took place at Sauer's home and that he moved McCoy's body to the parking lot and disposed of Gamez's body in an unknown location. A half-pound of methamphetamine was reportedly found at Sauer's residence upon his arrest.

Shortly after Sauer's arrest, his next-door neighbor, Thomas Lanham, was also arrested and faced the same charges: two counts of murder and two counts of tampering with physical evidence. The arrests, based on search warrants, phone records, and video evidence, seemed like a significant breakthrough for the grieving families who had waited two years for answers.

However, the path to justice proved to be complex and frustrating. In January 2020, the charges against Thomas Lanham were dropped. The Commonwealth Attorney's Office stated that DNA evidence—blood found in Lanham's car that was initially believed to be Gamez's—was determined not to be a match. A short time later, the murder charges against Larry Sauer were also dismissed due to issues with the DNA evidence.

Despite the legal setbacks, investigators have not given up. The case remains an active investigation for the Louisville Metro Police Department. In a significant development in March 2023, the LMPD, along with the FBI and Jeffersontown Police, executed a search warrant at the Ottawa Avenue home previously connected to the suspects. The search involved cadaver dogs and extensive digging in the yard, signaling a renewed effort to uncover new evidence. While authorities announced they had uncovered new information, they did not disclose what was found to protect the integrity of the ongoing case. As of March 2023, the families of Teressa McCoy and Austin Gamez continue to wait for justice, holding out hope that those responsible will be held accountable.