In the spring, a 36-year-old man named Gary Hayward was in Poipu, a picturesque area on the south shore of Kauai, Hawaii. He was a Caucasian male, standing at 5 feet 11 inches tall and weighing around 185 to 188 pounds. He had brown hair that was beginning to show signs of graying, and he wore a beard. His eyes were a distinct blue, and he had a scar on his right knee. On the day he was last seen, he was dressed casually in a white t-shirt, blue cut-off shorts, and tennis shoes. The exact date of his disappearance is uncertain, though it is often cited as May 2, 1987.
On that particular evening, Gary was at the Poipu Shores Bar. At some point, he mentioned to someone that he wanted to go for a swim. This was the last known communication anyone had with him. After leaving the bar, he seemingly vanished. He never went back to the condominium where he was staying, and no friends or family members have heard from him since that day. His disappearance was formally reported to the Kauai Police Department a couple of days later.
The years have turned into decades, and the case of Gary Hayward remains an unsolved mystery. Despite the passage of time, his whereabouts are still unknown. Information regarding the investigation into his disappearance is scarce, and there have been no significant leads to indicate what might have happened to him after he left the bar with the intention of going for a swim. The Kauai Police Department holds the case file, a reminder of a man who traveled to a beautiful island paradise and was never seen again. His case is a somber illustration of how a person can simply disappear, leaving behind only questions and a lingering sense of loss for those who knew him.
Last Seen: May 02, 1987
