Jennifer Hart and the 2018 Hart Family Murders
Overview of the Case
Jennifer Jean Hart was responsible for one of the most disturbing family murder-suicides in modern American history. On March 26, 2018, the 38-year-old intentionally drove her family's GMC Yukon XL off a coastal cliff along California State Route 1 near Westport in Mendocino County, California. Inside the vehicle were her wife, Sarah Hart, and their six adopted children: Markis, Hannah, Devonte, Jeremiah, Abigail and Ciera Hart. All eight members of the household died.
The deaths were initially investigated as a possible traffic accident. Evidence recovered from the vehicle, the crash site and the family's electronic devices eventually demonstrated that the plunge was deliberate. In April 2019, a Mendocino County coroner's jury unanimously concluded that Jennifer killed the six children and that Jennifer and Sarah died by suicide. The case was therefore classified as a murder-suicide rather than an accidental crash.
The Hart Household
Jennifer and Sarah Hart met while attending college and later formed a household that included six Black children adopted from the foster-care system. The family lived at different times in Minnesota, Oregon and Washington. Jennifer carefully promoted an idealized image of the household through photographs, social-media posts, music festivals and public appearances. She portrayed the family as affectionate, socially conscious and adventurous.
Behind that public image, however, teachers, friends, neighbors and child-welfare workers repeatedly received reports that the children were being physically abused, deprived of food, isolated and subjected to severe discipline. Jennifer was often described as the more controlling parent, while Sarah participated in the mistreatment and accepted legal responsibility for at least one documented assault.
Early Abuse Reports in Minnesota
Warning signs were documented as early as September 2008, when the family was living in Alexandria, Minnesota. A teacher noticed bruising on Hannah Hart's arm. Hannah reportedly said that Jennifer had struck her with a belt. Jennifer and Sarah denied responsibility and suggested that the injury could have resulted from a fall. No criminal charge followed that incident, and the children were soon removed from public school for a period of time.
In November 2010, Abigail Hart told a teacher that injuries on her back and stomach had been caused by one of her mothers. Investigators learned that Abigail had been punished over a penny that Jennifer and Sarah believed she had taken. Accounts of the punishment included hitting the child and forcing her head beneath cold water. Sarah eventually admitted striking Abigail and pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor domestic-assault charge. She received probation and community-service requirements.
The children also described food being withheld as punishment. In 2011, Hannah reportedly told a school nurse that she had not eaten that day. Sarah dismissed the disclosure by claiming that Hannah was attempting to manipulate adults with complaints about food. The children were later withdrawn from public school and educated at home, substantially reducing their regular contact with teachers and other adults who might have recognized continuing abuse.
...
MEMBER ACCESS
Continue reading the complete case summary
Unlock the full case narrative, source links, videos, victim information, and member discussions.
Unlock Full Case Access — $3.97/monthCancel anytime. Already a member?
Log in
