Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 3 sources
In the early days of Oklahoma statehood, Pleasant “Pleas” Yargee, a 24-year-old White / Caucasian man, served his community as a Deputy Sheriff with the Tulsa County Sheriff's Office. He was known for his dedication to upholding the law in a rapidly growing and often rough-edged region. In his personal life, he was a newlywed, having been married to his wife, Cassie, for just one year. Deputy Yargee’s commitment to public service was deeply felt, but it would ultimately lead him into a fatal confrontation, marking a tragic first for his department and leaving a lasting scar on the community he had sworn to protect. His death would be recorded as the first line-of-duty killing of a Tulsa County Deputy Sheriff.

The events that led to his death unfolded on the afternoon of Monday, October 18, 1909, in Tulsa. Deputy Yargee was off duty, participating in a local roping contest, when he noticed a gambler, later identified as Texas Graves, taking money from a young man who was clearly intoxicated. Seeing the youth being taken advantage of, Yargee stepped in to stop what he considered a robbery. The intervention sparked a heated argument, with harsh words exchanged between the deputy and the gambler. The verbal dispute quickly and violently escalated when both men drew their firearms.

Graves reportedly fired the first shot, which struck Deputy Yargee in his right arm. The bullet shattered the bone from his wrist all the way to his elbow. Despite the excruciating and disabling injury, Deputy Yargee managed to draw his own weapon and return fire, hitting Graves in the hip. The gunfight was not over. Graves fired again, and this time the bullet struck Yargee’s left hand, shooting off two of his fingers. After this exchange, the shooting stopped. The wounded gambler was arrested and taken to jail, while the gravely injured deputy was transported to his home in the nearby community of Red Fork, west of Tulsa, to begin what was hoped would be a steady recovery.

For a few days, it seemed that Deputy Yargee might survive his wounds. However, his condition took a devastating turn. A severe infection, diagnosed as blood poisoning, began to ravage his body, and gangrene set in on his shattered right arm. His family and local doctors, realizing his life was in grave danger, moved him to the West Side Hospital in Tulsa for more intensive medical intervention. In a last, desperate effort to stop the spread of the infection and save his life, surgeons made the difficult decision to amputate his entire right arm at the shoulder.

Tragically, the surgery was not enough to overcome the advanced stage of the infection. Deputy Sheriff Pleasant Yargee succumbed to his injuries on Tuesday, October 26, 1909. His death sent ripples of grief through his family and the local law enforcement community, who had lost a brave and committed officer. He was laid to rest in the Clinton Oaks Cemetery in Red Fork, leaving his young wife a widow after only a year of marriage.

In the aftermath of the shooting, Texas Graves was brought to trial for his part in the deputy’s death. The legal proceedings, however, did not result in a conviction. According to historical accounts, the prosecution’s case was fatally weakened by conflicting statements from various witnesses who had been at the roping contest. With no clear and unified account of how the gunfight began, the jury ultimately acquitted Graves. As a result, no one was ever held legally accountable for the death of Deputy Sheriff Pleas Yargee. More than a century later, his story remains a somber chapter in the history of Tulsa County, a poignant reminder of the dangers faced by law enforcement and the often-unpredictable path of justice in the American West.