Tyrone Elliott Kato Bautista, known to his loved ones as "Kato," was a young man remembered for his handsome face and beautiful smile. Born on April 22, 1983, he was a cherished son, brother, and friend. At 19 years old, the Coronado High School student had been a talented athlete in both baseball and track, with a promising life ahead of him. His family, including his mother, Jim, Ben, and Chrys, held him close in their hearts, a love that would be forced to endure an unimaginable and lasting grief.
The final hours of Tyrone’s life unfolded on the warm summer evening of August 1, 2002, in Colorado Springs, Colorado. He was visiting friends when he decided to walk to a nearby convenience store. There, he reportedly had a verbal altercation with several other young men. After the dispute, Tyrone returned to his friends' home on Payne Circle West and told them what had happened. A short time later, the argument tragically found its way to him.
Two cars, one described as a white two-door sedan, were seen driving slowly past the house.
The situation quickly escalated when one of the vehicles stopped. A number of men exited the car and began shouting at Tyrone. In response, Tyrone, who was carrying a handgun, moved toward the group. The men then got back into their car and started to drive away. As the vehicle pulled away, Tyrone gave chase on foot down Payne Circle. During the pursuit, a single shot rang out from the car, striking Tyrone in the chest.
Around 10:30 p.m., the Colorado Springs Police Department received calls reporting gunfire in the area. When officers arrived on the scene, they found Tyrone lying in the road. He had succumbed to the single gunshot wound and was pronounced dead. The suspects had fled, leaving a family and community devastated and searching for answers.
For years, the investigation into the homicide of Tyrone Bautista yielded no arrests and no publicly identified suspects. The case went cold, joining the list of the city's unsolved murders. His family marked the painful anniversaries of his death with public memorials, expressing their deep sorrow and their unwavering hope for a breakthrough. In a 2006 notice, they wrote, "We are still praying for justice to bring closure from this horrible crime. The candles are burning for truth to appear in Gods time." They held services at Evergreen Cemetery, where Tyrone was laid to rest, and released balloons on his birthday with messages of love they hoped would reach him in heaven.
For over a decade, justice for Tyrone remained elusive. However, a 2014 annual report published by the Colorado Springs Police Department listed the homicide of "Tyrone Bautista - 2001" as one of five cold cases that had been "cleared" by the unit that year. The year of the crime appears to be a typo, as all other records confirm Tyrone's death was in 2002.
Despite this official designation, there were no public announcements of an arrest, charges, or a trial in connection with the case, and no further details explaining the clearance have been made available. A case can be cleared "by exception" for reasons other than an arrest, such as the death of the primary suspect. Without more information, the exact resolution of the investigation remains unclear. The family's long wait for answers has been met with an official but silent closure, leaving the full story of what happened that night on Payne Circle West known only to those who were there.