Lester Edward Dodd, a 38-year-old male, was killed on October 16, 1994, in what became a grim discovery at the Changing Times Lounge in Birmingham, Alabama. Dodd, who worked at the neighborhood bar, was found alongside his wife, Pamela Jo Hogg Dodd, 37, and three regular patrons: Florence Adell Elliott, 44, James Ormand Watkins, 59, and William Nelson, 52.
The scene suggested a brutal, calculated act, with the victims positioned in a manner that indicated 'execution-style' killings.
The investigation into the five murders led authorities to Stephen Pilley and Andrew Apicella. Witnesses recalled seeing the two men, who were not regular customers, in the bar on the night of the killings. Pilley was reportedly seen wandering around the bar and at one point inquired if Edward Dodd owned the establishment and if he was armed. Testimony also revealed that Pilley had been overheard discussing obtaining weapons and 'easy money' earlier that night.
Stephen Pilley was subsequently arrested and charged with capital murder for the five deaths. During his trial, the prosecution presented evidence placing him at the scene and detailing his suspicious behavior. The evidence suggested that two different weapons were used in the commission of the crimes. The jury found Pilley guilty, and in a unanimous decision, recommended the death penalty. On May 30, 1997, a judge sentenced Stephen Pilley to death for his role in the murders.
