Joseph Agee III, a 29-year-old Black man, was serving a life sentence at the William E. Donaldson Correctional Facility in Bessemer, Alabama, when his life was cut short on Monday, October 3, 2022. He had been incarcerated since he was a teenager, convicted of a murder that occurred in 2012. Inside the prison walls, he became another victim of the violence that plagued the state's correctional system.
The day of the fatal incident was described as one of the deadlier days for Alabama's incarcerated population, with two other men dying in different state facilities on the same day. According to the Jefferson County Coroner’s Office and the Alabama Department of Corrections (ADOC), Joseph was the victim of an inmate-on-inmate assault. He sustained multiple sharp force injuries during the attack. Prison staff moved him to the facility's health care unit, where they attempted life-saving measures.
Their efforts were unsuccessful, and Joseph was pronounced dead shortly after the assault. His death was officially classified as a homicide.
The investigation was immediately taken over by the Law Enforcement Services Division of the Alabama Department of Corrections. An ADOC spokesperson confirmed that another incarcerated man was quickly taken into custody as a suspect in connection with the fatal assault. Authorities did not release the name of the individual taken into custody or elaborate on the motive or the specific circumstances that led to the deadly confrontation.
Joseph’s death occurred during a period of significant turmoil within Alabama's prisons. At the time, thousands of inmates across the state were engaged in a widespread labor strike, refusing to work in protest of what they described as inhumane conditions. Activists and incarcerated individuals cited pervasive violence, understaffing, corruption, a lack of opportunities for parole, and an alarming increase in inmate deaths as reasons for the protest. Joseph's killing was one of at least three to occur since the strike began in late September 2022. His was the second fatal stabbing at the Donaldson facility in just a few days, following the death of Denarieya Smith on October 1.
The violence at Donaldson was not an isolated issue. The U.S. Department of Justice had filed a lawsuit against the Alabama prison system in 2020, alleging that the state failed to protect male prisoners from unconstitutional levels of violence, excessive force from staff, and sexual assault. While the state acknowledged it had problems, it disputed the Justice Department's claims. By the time of Joseph's death, the number of inmate deaths at the Donaldson facility for the year had already surpassed the total from the previous year, underscoring the dangerous environment.
Incarcerated activists and their families on the outside had been pleading with state officials for reform. Their demands included clearer parole guidelines, an end to life-without-parole sentences, and the creation of a conviction integrity unit. Diyawn Caldwell, an activist with the group Both Sides of the Wall, questioned how Governor Kay Ivey could call their demands "unreasonable" without ever meeting with the families to understand their proposals.
The investigation into the homicide of Joseph Agee III was turned over to the ADOC's Law Enforcement Services Division. As of October 2022, the case was proceeding through the justice system, with a fellow inmate in custody as the primary suspect. The case is listed as being in the litigation phase.