Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 3 sources
Andrew Norman Coit was an 18-year-old man with a future full of promise. A senior honor student at Coventry High School in Rhode Island, he was known for his love of music and his involvement in the school’s Drama Club. His family remembered him as a bright and creative young man on the cusp of major life milestones; at the time of his death, Andrew was expecting a child and was about to become a father. He was the beloved son of Christa Mills and Alan Coit, and a cherished brother to his sister, Samantha.

The night of Friday, March 23, 2007, was marked by tragedy for Andrew’s circle of friends. A 14-year-old friend had been killed in a single-car accident in West Warwick. In the pre-dawn hours of Saturday, March 24, a group of grieving friends, including Andrew, gathered for a roadside vigil on Main Street to honor the young victim’s memory. According to friends, Andrew brought his guitar to the makeshift memorial to play a song for his departed friend. It was a final, heartfelt tribute.

At approximately 4:00 a.m., as the mourners stood together in the darkness, a second tragedy struck. A vehicle appeared on Main Street, struck Andrew, and then sped away from the scene. The driver did not stop, leaving the young man fatally injured amidst his shocked and horrified friends. Andrew Coit, who had come to mourn a life cut short, had his own life stolen in a heartless act of vehicular violence. The driver and the vehicle have never been identified.

The West Warwick Police Department launched an investigation into the fatal hit-and-run, but the case quickly went cold. With no suspect and few leads, years passed without answers for Andrew’s devastated family. The pain was compounded for the family ten years later with the unexpected passing of Andrew's sister, Samantha, in 2017. The weight of these losses was immense, yet their quest for justice for Andrew never faded.

In 2019, Rhode Island law enforcement agencies created a novel tool to help solve cold cases: a deck of playing cards, with each card featuring an unsolved homicide or missing person case. Andrew Coit’s story was featured on one of the cards, which were distributed to inmates in state correctional facilities in the hope of generating new tips. The initiative brought renewed attention to Andrew’s case, and his family voiced their enduring hope for a breakthrough. "I don't know how they can sleep every night," a family member said in a May 2019 television interview. "I need to see justice."

As of May 2019, the hit-and-run death of Andrew Coit remains an unsolved homicide. The person who was behind the wheel on that tragic morning has kept their secret for more than a decade, leaving a family to navigate a future without their son, brother, and the father their grandchild would never know. The West Warwick Police Department continues to seek information that could finally identify the driver and bring a measure of closure to Andrew's loved ones. Anyone with information regarding this case is encouraged to contact the West Warwick Police Department at (401) 821-4323.