Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 4 sources
Anthony Colucci was a hard-working 20-year-old man from Pittsfield, Massachusetts, who was building a life for himself as a mason. Loved by his family, which included his parents, a sister, and a younger brother, Anthony was known as a good kid who was reliable and close to his loved ones. He was the kind of son who wouldn't just take off without telling anyone where he was going. His family remembers him as a beloved son whose absence has left a scar that reopens each year.

The Fourth of July holiday in 2005 was the last time his family knew him to be safe. Anthony had plans to meet friends to watch a local fireworks display but he never arrived. When he didn't show up for work the next day and calls to his cellphone went unanswered, his parents grew deeply worried. His father, John Colucci, later recalled having a bad feeling, knowing it was entirely out of character for his son to be out of touch. The family's fears intensified five days later when Anthony’s pickup truck was found abandoned in October Mountain State Forest in the nearby town of Lee, Massachusetts. His father said Anthony had no reason to be there.

The discovery of the truck launched an extensive search of the vast state forest. For nearly two weeks, a multi-agency effort involving law enforcement, K-9 units, helicopters, ATVs, and hundreds of volunteers scoured the rugged terrain. The search came to a tragic end on July 18, 2005, when searchers found Anthony’s body. He had been deliberately concealed under a covering of brush, branches, and leaves. An autopsy later confirmed the cause of death was homicide; he had been stabbed multiple times in the chest. The condition of his body, affected by weather and animals, delayed official identification for more than a week.

The investigation into the murder of Anthony Colucci, a male, is led by the Massachusetts State Police assigned to the Berkshire District Attorney's Office. Over the years, investigators have pursued various leads. In 2007, Anthony's father mentioned that police had a suspect in mind but lacked sufficient evidence to press charges. More recently, state police have publicly noted they are looking into any potential connection to William S. Demagall of New York. Demagall is not officially a suspect, but Anthony's body was found less than five miles from where another stabbing victim was discovered. To generate new leads, Anthony’s case was included in a cold case playing card deck distributed in Massachusetts state prisons, with his story featured on one of the cards.

For more than two decades, Anthony's family has lived with the pain of not knowing who was responsible for his death. His father, John, has been a vocal advocate for his son, joining support groups like the Merrimack Valley Parents of Murdered Children. "It's so hard," he said in an interview. "I wouldn't wish this on anybody." The holidays are particularly difficult, especially the Fourth of July, which marks the anniversary of Anthony’s disappearance. "Don't forget my son," his father has pleaded.

The family remains in contact with law enforcement and the Berkshire District Attorney's Office, holding onto hope that advancements in DNA technology will one day break the case open. "It’s just a matter of time," John Colucci wrote in a letter published in July 2026, 21 years after the murder. "With advancements in DNA technology, it will happen and justice will prevail."

As of July 2026, the homicide of Anthony Colucci remains unsolved. The Massachusetts State Police continue to seek information from the public that could finally lead to an arrest. They urge anyone with information, no matter how insignificant it may seem, to come forward. Tips can be called in to the state police toll-free line at 1-855-MA-SOLVE or emailed to [email protected].