Andrew Jr. Davis, an 18-year-old known to his loved ones as “A.J.,” was a gifted and passionate artist with a bright future ahead of him. He was a student at Fort Hayes Metropolitan Education Center in Columbus, Ohio, a magnet high school known for its intensive arts and academic curriculum. There, A.J. honed his talents, eagerly sharing his work and showing immense promise. Remembered by his family as fun-loving, kind, intelligent, and brilliantly smart beyond his years, A.J. was the cherished son of Vincent and Leslie Davis and a brother to Vincent II and Brian. He was a beloved member of a large family that included his maternal grandmother, Nellie Carter, a nephew, and several nieces, aunts, uncles, and cousins.
The afternoon of Thursday, June 27, 2013, shattered his family’s world. At approximately 2:15 p.m., A.J. was standing in the front yard of his home in the 1400 block of Myrtle Avenue in the North Linden neighborhood of Columbus.
In a sudden act of violence, an unidentified person approached and shot him. According to his mother, it was a drive-by shooting, and the single gunshot struck A.J. in the neck. His older brother, Vince, was the first to reach him.
Multiple frantic calls flooded into 911 dispatch, reporting shots fired and a person down. One of the callers was A.J.’s girlfriend, who was present during the horrific event. When Columbus Police officers and emergency responders arrived, they found A.J. gravely wounded. He was rushed to Riverside Methodist Hospital, but despite the efforts of medical staff, he succumbed to his injury and was pronounced dead. His mother later shared the heartbreaking detail that her son died in his brother's arms.
The Columbus Police Department immediately launched a homicide investigation, but the case quickly grew cold. Detectives sought witnesses and information, and in the months that followed, Central Ohio Crime Stoppers issued public appeals hoping to generate new leads. They urged anyone with knowledge of the shooting to come forward, stressing that even the smallest detail could be crucial. However, no suspects were ever publicly identified, and no arrests have been made in connection with A.J.'s murder.
The senseless killing left an unfillable void in the Davis family, a wound tragically deepened just 18 months later when A.J.'s older brother, Vincent II, who had held him in his final moments, was killed in a car accident. His mother, Leslie, has said that the family lost both of their sons on the day A.J. was murdered, as Vince was never the same. Their surviving son, Brian, continues to struggle with the trauma and loss. A.J.’s family and friends gathered to celebrate his life on July 5, 2013, at The Word Church of God in Christ before laying him to rest at Glen Rest Memorial Estates in Reynoldsburg.
Years later, the case of Andrew “A.J.” Davis’s murder remains unsolved and is now in the hands of the Columbus Police Homicide Cold Case Unit. Investigators and his family are still waiting for the information that will lead to an arrest and bring a measure of justice for a young man whose artistic potential was stolen from him and his community. Anyone with information about the shooting is asked to contact the Columbus Police Homicide Cold Case Unit or Central Ohio Crime Stoppers at 614-461-8477.