206 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.
Case Description
Any updates on this case?
Sarah McQuillan, a white female of Irish descent, was murdered in 1891 in Burlingham, New York. She was one of the victims of Lizzie Halliday, an Irish-American serial killer. Sarah and her mother, Margaret McQuillan, had previously provided lodging to Halliday in Philadelphia. Their bodies were discovered buried under hay on the Halliday property, both having been shot.
Lizzie Halliday was arrested and charged with the murders of Sarah and Margaret McQuillan, as well as her ...Read More
Lizzie Halliday was arrested and charged with the murders of Sarah and Margaret McQuillan, as well as her ...Read More
Links to Additional Sources (3)
See any mistakes?Victim Details
Sarah McQuillan
Female
White / Caucasian
Burlingham
NY
1891
Sarah
McQuillan
11/28/2025
Forum Posts (2)
I've been researching the McQuillan case and can't stop thinking about the tragic turn of events tha... ...Read More
10/09/2024
10/09/2024
Has anyone else thought about the role Sarah McQuillan might have played in Lizzie Halliday’s web ... ...Read More
02/02/2024
02/02/2024
