Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 1 source
Do you know who killed Evelyn Halsey in 1984?
Evelyn Halsey, a 74-year-old woman, was known in her Yuma, Arizona, neighborhood for her quiet independence. She lived on her own and took care of her own affairs, a familiar presence to those on her street. But in the spring of 1984, that familiar routine was broken. Neighbors noticed that newspapers were beginning to collect on her doorstep, and a general sense of unease grew when she wasn't seen for several days. The concern prompted a call for a welfare check on her home.

On the afternoon of April 16, 1984, at around 1:30 p.m., a worker from the Meals on Wheels program arrived at Halsey’s residence at 2103 South 11th Avenue. After receiving no answer at the door, the Yuma Police Department was dispatched to the scene. Upon entering the house, officers made a devastating discovery. Halsey was found deceased inside, the victim of a brutal and violent assault.

The scene painted a grim picture for investigators. Evidence indicated that Halsey had been sexually assaulted. The official cause of death was determined to be a broken back. According to police, it appeared the attack began outside the home, possibly in her driveway. Investigators believe she was killed there and then dragged into the residence. Despite the violence of the crime, robbery was ruled out as a motive, leaving the community and law enforcement struggling to understand the reason for such a vicious attack on an elderly woman. In the months prior to the murder, there had been reports of prowlers in the area, but no definitive link to Halsey's case was ever established.

For decades, the murder of Evelyn Halsey remained one of Yuma's most troubling cold cases. The trail went cold, and with no new leads, it seemed justice might never be found. The case was a lingering wound for the community and a constant puzzle for the Yuma Police Department, which lists her name among more than a dozen other unsolved homicides stretching back to the 1960s. Detectives periodically reviewed the file, hoping that a new perspective or a forgotten piece of evidence might break the silence.

Then, 32 years after the murder, a significant breakthrough occurred thanks to advancements in forensic science. DNA evidence collected from the 1984 crime scene was re-examined and yielded a match. The genetic profile pointed to a specific individual: a man who had been in the military and was stationed in Yuma at the time of Halsey's death. It was the critical piece of the puzzle that investigators had been missing for more than three decades. Detectives pursued the new lead with a renewed sense of purpose, hoping to finally close the case and provide answers.

Tragically, the path to justice had another cruel twist. After leaving the military, the suspect had moved to Texas. By the time Yuma police investigators tracked him down, they learned he was already deceased. While the DNA match brought a degree of certainty about who was responsible for the horrific crime, the suspect’s death meant he could never be held accountable in a court of law. As of January 2024, the case is considered cleared, but it remains officially unsolved because no arrest can be made. The Yuma Police Department continues to seek information on its cold cases and encourages anyone with knowledge to come forward. Tips can be submitted to the department at 928-373-4700 or anonymously by calling 78-CRIME.

Links to Additional Sources (1)

See any mistakes? Let us know!