Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 8 sources
Michael Marshall, a 50-year-old Black man from Eufaula, Alabama, was a brother whose life was cut short over a small debt on a summer afternoon. His death on Father's Day, June 21, 2015, stemmed from a violent confrontation that also left his younger brother wounded and ultimately led to a long-overdue murder conviction nearly seven years later.

That Sunday, Michael and his 49-year-old brother, Marvin Marshall, went to the home of Reginald Dejuan Coley on Deerfield Drive to resolve a dispute. According to Marvin, they were there to settle a $40 debt. He maintained that he and his brother were unarmed. "We pulled away from the residence, he called us back pretending to pay a debt, he called us back to execute us," Marvin later recounted. The attempt to collect the money turned deadly when Coley opened fire on the brothers with what police believe was a .40 caliber handgun.

After being shot, the brothers managed to flee in their 1993 red Ford pickup truck. Michael was driving but soon collapsed from his injuries, bringing the truck to a stop in a field at the corner of Deerfield Drive and North Eufaula Avenue. Police responded to a shooting call at 1:18 p.m. and found the two men with the vehicle, both suffering from apparent gunshot wounds. Emergency medical units arrived and transported both brothers to Medical Center Barbour. Michael Marshall did not survive his injuries. Marvin was hospitalized and later released.

The suspected shooter, 43-year-old Reginald Coley, was quickly identified and located at his home at 16 Deerfield Drive. He initially refused to follow police instructions to surrender, resulting in a brief standoff. The area was secured by the Eufaula Police Department, the Barbour County Sheriff's Office, and the Barbour County District Attorney's Office. The standoff ended peacefully when Coley surrendered to the police. He was arrested and charged with murder for Michael Marshall's death and first-degree assault for the shooting of Marvin Marshall.

Eufaula's police chief stated that physical evidence, including drugs recovered from the scene, suggested a possible drug-related motive. Marvin Marshall later publicly criticized the emergency response, claiming it took over an hour for EMS to arrive while his brother "bled out and died." The police chief addressed this concern, stating that dispatch records documented a very rapid response and suggested that the trauma of the event could have skewed Marvin's perception of time.

The case against Reginald Coley moved slowly through the justice system. At trial, Coley claimed self-defense, but prosecutors presented evidence that there was no indication he had been assaulted. When police searched his property after the shooting, they discovered marijuana, crack cocaine, and cocaine hidden in a deep freezer in a shed. On February 11, 2022, a Barbour County Circuit Court jury convicted Coley of the murder of Michael Marshall. He was also found guilty of second-degree assault, unlawful possession of marijuana, and unlawful possession with intent to distribute a controlled substance.

Coley was sentenced to 40 years in prison for the murder conviction, with concurrent two-year sentences for his various drug convictions. He later appealed the verdict, but the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed his convictions on February 3, 2023, ensuring that he would be held accountable for the killing of Michael Marshall. The case is now considered closed, with justice for Michael and his family delivered after a nearly seven-year wait.