Louise McMillen was a 16-year-old girl from the East Side of Providence, Rhode Island, who spent her summers with family at their home in the Bonnet Shores neighborhood of Narragansett. In the summer of 1969, she was looking forward to the future, but a shopping trip to a local town cut her life tragically short in a crime that has remained unsolved for decades.
On the afternoon of June 17, 1969, Louise left her family’s summer residence to drive to Wakefield. She planned to return some clothing she had bought at Kenyon's Department Store. She never made it home. Later that same day, her car, a blue Buick Skylark, was found abandoned on Oak Dell Street in the neighboring town of South Kingstown. Investigators processed the vehicle and discovered a single, unidentified fingerprint on the steering wheel, a small clue in a case that would soon grow much darker.
Her parents reported her missing to the Narragansett Police, sparking a frantic search.
The search for Louise ended in heartbreak three weeks later. On July 8, 1969, her badly decomposed body was discovered in a wooded area. She was found on the side of a path nearly 200 feet off Broad Rock Road in South Kingstown. The condition of her remains indicated she had been there for some time. The discovery launched a major homicide investigation involving both South Kingstown Police and Rhode Island State Police, who worked tirelessly in the immediate aftermath.
The investigation into the heinous crime was extensive from the start. Then-Rhode Island Attorney General Herbert DeSimone announced that all physical evidence, which included a knife, McMillen's purse, her jewelry, and clothing found at the scene, had been sent to the Federal Bureau of Investigation for analysis. In the month that followed the discovery of Louise's body, police interviewed more than 100 people, hoping to find a lead or a witness. Despite the exhaustive, 24-hour investigation, the scientific testing available at the time yielded no definitive suspect, and no arrests were ever made.
For nearly half a century, the case grew cold. The mystery of who killed Louise McMillen haunted her family and the community. But about six years before 2016, Louise’s younger brother formally asked police to take another look at his sister's murder. This request, combined with new information that authorities received, prompted the South Kingstown Police Department to officially reopen the investigation in March 2016. Detectives began re-examining all the evidence, both old and new.
With the case reopened, investigators hoped that advances in forensic science could finally break the decades-long stalemate. Evidence that had been carefully preserved since 1969, including Louise's clothing and personal items, was submitted for modern DNA analysis, a tool unavailable to the original detectives. By early 2016, police had developed new evidence and narrowed their focus to multiple persons of interest. Two South Kingstown officers even reviewed NBC 10 News footage from 1969 as part of their renewed efforts.
As of November 2019, the murder of Louise McMillen remained an open and active investigation in South Kingstown, with her killer still unidentified. Police continue to hope that someone might remember a small detail that could be the missing piece of the puzzle. Anyone with information about the case is urged to contact the South Kingstown Police Department at 401-783-3321.