Matthew McDaniel, 42, male, White / Caucasian, was shot on a summer Saturday in Colerain Township, a Cincinnati neighborhood along Geraldine Drive, after what police described as an argument that began in the street. Officers were dispatched at about 8:07 p.m. and found Matthew McDaniel with multiple gunshot wounds; he was rushed to the University of Cincinnati Medical Center and, according to the Hamilton County Coroner and funeral records, died days later on August 19, 2025.
In the first days after the shooting, investigators said they knew who had allegedly pulled the trigger and initially listed a nearby neighbor—37 years old—as a suspect. Accounts gathered by police described a prior confrontation between the men, and a 911 caller from the victim’s home recounted escalating tension that spilled into the street before shots were fired. Even then, authorities held off on immediate charges while they pieced together what happened between neighbors whose dispute had reportedly simmered before that night.
As detectives worked the case, they focused not only on the moments of gunfire but also on what happened to the weapons afterward. By late September, police announced that no murder charges would be filed in Matthew McDaniel’s death; after a review with the Hamilton County Prosecutor’s Office, they said the shooting was legally justified under Ohio’s self-defense law. At the same time, they arrested two men on tampering-with-evidence charges: 37-year-old Perez Crossty, accused of trying to hide his gun before later telling officers where it was, and 26-year-old David Heimpold, accused of removing a second gun from the scene that investigators said had been in Matthew McDaniel’s possession.
The official timeline places the violence on August 16, 2025, and the death that followed three days later at the hospital. Public memorial pages mark the loss of Matthew McDaniel, 42, in Cincinnati on August 16 as the date of the shooting, while the coroner and obituary confirm his death occurred on August 19. The case, shaped by a neighborhood dispute that flared into fatal gunfire and by post-incident decisions about the guns involved, ended without a homicide charge but with arrests linked to what police say happened in the minutes after the shots were fired.
