Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 35 sources
In the quiet town of Pawlet, Vermont, the life of a 41-year-old Caucasian woman, Erica Pawlusiak Crossman, was brought to a tragic end on September 15, 2024. The grim discovery was made in the early morning hours after state police received a call about a suspicious person, which led them to the family's residence on Vermont Route 133. Inside the home, a horrific scene awaited the troopers: Erica, her husband Brian Crossman Sr., 46, and her 13-year-old son, Colin Taft, were all found deceased. The medical examiner would later determine that Erica died from a single gunshot wound to the head. Both her death and the deaths of her husband and son were officially ruled as homicides.

The investigation into the triple homicide quickly focused on a member of their own family. The "suspicious person" reported to the police turned out to be Erica's stepson, Brian Crossman Jr., who was 23 years old at the time. He was found with his clothes covered in blood and initially told investigators that he had been out for a walk and returned to find his family members dead. He claimed the blood on his clothes came from an attempt to move his father's body. However, investigators found that the evidence inside the home, including blood patterns, contradicted his account of the events.

As the investigation deepened, a troubled history came to light. Family members told police about the younger Crossman's long-standing mental health challenges and a strained relationship with his father. It was revealed that Erica herself had expressed fear about being alone in the house with her stepson. He was visiting for the weekend when the killings occurred. Based on what they described as "significant evidence," including digital information and interviews, Vermont State Police secured an arrest warrant for Brian Crossman Jr. He was taken into custody in Granville, New York, and charged with three counts of aggravated murder in the deaths of his father, his stepmother Erica, and his stepbrother Colin.

Links to Additional Sources (35)

See any mistakes? Let us know!
  • ABC News: Son arrested in the murder of his father, stepmom and stepbrother: Police
  • WCVB: New England town official, wife, teen son dead in triple homicide, police say
  • NECN: Man charged in fatal shootings of father, stepmom, stepbrother in Vermont
  • VTDigger: State police identify Pawlet Selectboard member and family members as victims in triple-homicide - VTDigger
  • https://www.wcax.com: Police confirm identities of Pawlet triple-murder victims
  • Who is Brian Crossman Jr.? Town Official's Son Charged With ...
  • Grisly new details in Pawlet triple homicide - NEWS10 ABC
  • Vermont State Police identifies victims in Pawlet homicide ...
  • Update No. 4: Suspect in Pawlet triple homicide makes initial court ...
  • Insurance company sues over triple homicide case in Pawlet
  • Suspect in the murders of 3 family members in Pawlet ... - VTDigger
  • Erica Hewitt-Crossman - Obituary Listings - Ducharme Funeral Home
  • Man accused of killing 3 family members had cellphone ... - CBS News
  • Insurance firm ponders paying out on death policy in triple homicide ...
  • Police arrest relative in Pawlet triple murder - VTDigger
  • Select Board member Brian Crossman
  • Son Accused of Killing Father
  • Granville man at center of triple homicide now named in life ...
  • Suspect in Pawlet triple homicide makes initial court ...
  • Man pleads not guilty to 3 counts of aggravated murder in Pawlet ...
  • Erica Pawlusiak Crossman, age 41 - National Gun Violence Memorial
  • Insurance company sues over triple-homicide case in Pawlet
  • Pawlet triple murder suspect due back in court on Thursday - WCAX
  • Pawlet Murder Suspect Alarmed Family Members Before Killings
  • Select Board member Brian Crossman, wife Erica among three ...
  • Court records give details in Pawlet killings - Rutland Herald
  • Pawlet triple murder suspect's extradition could take over a month
  • Pawlet town official, his wife and her son found shot to ...
  • Erica Hewitt-Crossman Obituary September 15, 2024
  • Erica Hewitt-Crossman Obituary | 1983 - 2024 | Castleton, VT
  • Alleged Pawlet killer to return to Vermont - Rutland Herald
  • Erica D. Hewitt-Crossman | Obituaries | rutlandherald.com
  • Vermont State Police confirm identities of Pawlet triple-murder victims
  • Vermont town official, his wife and her son found shot to death in ...
  • Year in Review: Killings shock Pawlet community - Rutland Herald