Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 3 sources
Diane Cusack, a 55-year-old woman from New Britain, Connecticut, had been out of touch with her family for several years when she disappeared in the summer of 2003. Because of this estrangement, she was never officially reported as a missing person. Police last had contact with the White/Caucasian woman on July 9, 2003, for a routine dispute with her landlord at her home at 189 Oak Street. After that, her life and whereabouts became a quiet mystery. She was known to have struggled with substance abuse, a vulnerability she shared with several other women who frequented the same downtown New Britain neighborhoods.

The case began to unfold on August 20, 2007, when a man scouting for a place to hunt walked into a swampy, 15-acre wooded area behind a shopping plaza at 593 Hartford Road in New Britain. There, he discovered skeletal remains. The discovery triggered an extensive search of the property, and over the next few days, investigators unearthed the remains of three different women. The condition of the bodies made identification a slow and difficult process, relying on complex forensic analysis. It took more than three years before investigators, with the help of public tips and DNA, could confirm that some of the remains belonged to Diane Cusack. The announcement of her identification was made in January 2011.

The investigation revealed that Diane was one of multiple victims of a serial killer. The remains of Joyvaline Martinez and Mary Jane Menard were also found in the same wooded plot in 2007. All three women had vanished in 2003. The grim site, which the killer later called his "garden," was revisited by a serial killer task force in April 2015. With the help of an FBI cadaver dog, investigators found the remains of four more victims, bringing the total to seven. This discovery confirmed that a prolific serial killer had been operating in the area.

The prime suspect was identified as William Devin Howell, a drifter from Hampton, Virginia, who had been doing odd jobs and mowing lawns in central Connecticut in 2003. At the time of the discoveries, Howell was already in prison, serving a 15-year sentence for the 2003 manslaughter of another woman, Nilsa Arizmendi, whose body was among the four found in 2015. Evidence from Howell's van, including bloodstains, had linked him to Arizmendi's disappearance years earlier.

In September 2015, authorities charged Howell with the murders of Diane Cusack, Joyvaline Martinez, Mary Jane Menard, and three other victims whose remains were identified. Court documents painted a horrific picture of his crimes. Howell had confessed to a cellmate that there was a "monster inside him," describing himself as a "sick ripper." He detailed sexually assaulting some of his victims and keeping one woman's body in his van for two weeks, sleeping beside her and calling her his "baby." He told the inmate the victims should have known they were going to die because of the lifestyles they led.

On November 17, 2017, William Devin Howell pleaded guilty to the murders of Diane Cusack and five other women: Mary Jane Menard, Joyvaline Martinez, Melanie Ruth Camilini, Marilyn Gonzalez, and Janice Roberts. He was already serving a sentence for the manslaughter of Nilsa Arizmendi. During his sentencing, Howell cried and apologized to the victims' families, calling his actions "monstrous, cowardly and selfish." He said he deserved the death penalty, which Connecticut had abolished in 2015.

Howell, believed to be the most prolific serial killer in Connecticut's history, was sentenced to six consecutive life sentences, ensuring he will die in prison. At the hearing, the daughter of victim Mary Jane Menard called Howell a "monster" who "stripped away the youth from us and made me and my brother orphans." The case is considered closed, with the perpetrator behind bars for the rest of his life.