Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 2 sources
On a cold December morning, the quiet landscape near the entrance of East Rock Park in New Haven, Connecticut, became the scene of a grim discovery. Shortly after midnight on December 15, 2007, a passing motorist spotted what appeared to be a body in the snow on Farnam Drive and alerted two nearby police officers. The officers found 32-year-old Jeremiah Johnson, a Black male from New Haven, lying face down. He had been shot multiple times in the head and back and was pronounced dead at the hospital. The discovery of his body marked the city’s 13th homicide of the year.

For nearly five years, the investigation into who killed Jeremiah Johnson remained cold. New Haven police detectives worked the case, but no arrests were made, and the public heard little about any progress. The area where Johnson was found, near the Hamden town line, is typically a peaceful section of the city, which left the community unsettled by the violent nature of the crime. Investigators initially were unsure if Johnson had been killed at that location or if his body had been left there after the fact.

A major breakthrough finally came in May 2012, when the New Haven Police Department announced it had secured arrest warrants for two men. The suspects were identified as Zackery Cody Franklin, then 21, and his alleged accomplice, John Torry Denby, 27. Police stated that the motive for the killing was robbery. At the time the warrants were issued, both men were already incarcerated on unrelated charges. Denby was being held on drug-related offenses, while Franklin was jailed on bonds totaling over $5.6 million, accused in three other homicides that occurred in 2011.

Franklin, who was just 17 at the time of Johnson's death, was linked to a string of violent crimes. In addition to the charge for Johnson's murder, he was accused of killing Ryan Barnaby in Edgewood Park during a gun sale in May 2011. Two months later, in July 2011, he was allegedly involved in two more killings: the murder of John-Claude James in New Haven during a robbery for a gold chain, and another homicide in Waterbury during an attempt to steal a three-wheeled motorcycle on his own 21st birthday. After this violent spree, Franklin fled Connecticut but was apprehended in Virginia in November 2011.

As the cases against the two men proceeded, their paths through the justice system diverged. In April 2014, prosecutors dropped the felony murder charge against John Torry Denby, citing a lack of sufficient evidence to move forward to trial. The primary evidence against him was reportedly a statement he had allegedly made to another person claiming responsibility. While maintaining his innocence in Johnson's death, Denby pleaded guilty to separate narcotics charges.

Zackery Cody Franklin, however, faced accountability for his role in the death of Jeremiah Johnson as part of a global resolution for the four homicides he was charged with committing. In February 2015, Franklin pleaded guilty to a lesser charge of first-degree manslaughter for killing Johnson. He was sentenced to 25 years in prison for that crime. This sentence was part of a larger plea agreement that resulted in a total sentence of 195 years for the four separate slayings. The judge in court noted that he had never before seen a defendant responsible for four separate, unrelated homicides. As of February 2015, the case of Jeremiah Johnson's death was officially closed, with his killer sentenced to spend the rest of his life behind bars.