Arglister Cheatham, a 34-year-old Black man known to some as "2 Jr," was a graduate of Green Oaks High School in Shreveport, Louisiana, and worked at Gateway Tire. He was a father and a member of a large family with deep roots in the Shreveport community. His life was abruptly and violently ended on the last night of March in 2015.
Just before 10 p.m. on Tuesday, March 31, 2015, officers from the Shreveport Police Department responded to calls reporting shots fired in the Southern Hills neighborhood. The first officer to arrive, Corporal Vincent Webb, discovered a horrifying scene in the 9300 block of Normandie Drive. Arglister Cheatham was lying motionless in the middle of the street, having sustained at least one fatal gunshot wound. As the officer approached, he saw a dark-colored sedan speeding away from the area, running over Cheatham's body in its haste.
As the car fled, the officer discharged his service weapon at the vehicle.
Other responding officers spotted the car traveling north on Mansfield Road and attempted a traffic stop, but the driver refused to pull over, initiating a high-speed pursuit. The chase ended after police briefly lost sight of the vehicle, only to receive a report that a similar car had crashed through a fence near Hollywood Avenue and West 70th Street. With the assistance of a police K-9 unit, officers located and arrested the driver, 27-year-old Marques Wilson, near the crash site. Wilson was suffering from a gunshot wound to his leg and was transported to a local hospital for treatment before being booked into the Shreveport City Jail on a charge of aggravated flight from an officer. Investigators later determined the bullet that struck Wilson did not come from the officer's weapon.
The investigation into Cheatham's murder was handled by the Shreveport Police Department's Violent Crimes unit. Detectives worked to determine the full extent of Wilson's involvement while searching for at least one other suspect. Within two weeks, their investigation led them to identify a primary person of interest. On April 13, 2015, authorities announced they had secured an arrest warrant for 44-year-old Jake Smith III, of Monroe, Louisiana. The warrant, signed by a Caddo Parish District Judge, was for a single count of second-degree murder, and bond was set at $250,000.
Law enforcement asked the public for help locating Smith, and the search did not last long. Three days later, on the morning of April 16, 2015, members of the U.S. Marshals Fugitive Task Force located and arrested Jake Smith III at a residence in Winnsboro, Louisiana, a town about 80 miles east of Shreveport. He was taken into custody without incident and transported back to Shreveport, where he was booked into the Caddo Correctional Center to face the second-degree murder charge in connection with Arglister Cheatham's death.
Following his arrest, Jake Smith III was indicted by a grand jury on the charge of second-degree murder. Court records show that in January 2017, he pleaded guilty to a lesser charge of manslaughter. For his role in the killing of Arglister Cheatham, Smith was sentenced by a Caddo District Court judge to serve 25 years in prison at hard labor.
The case, which began with a call about gunfire and unfolded into a dramatic police pursuit and a multi-agency manhunt, concluded with a conviction. The investigation by the Shreveport Police Department and the subsequent arrest by the U.S. Marshals Task Force ensured that the man responsible for Arglister Cheatham's death was held accountable for his actions. As of January 2017, the legal proceedings in the homicide of Arglister Cheatham were officially closed.