Michelle Benjamin Missing from Saint Marys, Pennsylvania age 35

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!

Michelle Lynn Benjamin, a 35-year-old woman from Saint Marys, Pennsylvania, was last seen on June 22, 2007. She was reportedly at her residence on Madison Street that afternoon. According to witnesses, Michelle may have left her home in a red or maroon 1992 Buick sedan with three men, believed to be from Buffalo, New York. It is speculated that she might have traveled to the Buffalo area with these individuals.

Michelle's disappearance is considered suspicious, as her family and friend ...Read More
Last Seen: Jun 22, 2007

Links to Additional Sources (6)

See any mistakes? Let us know!

Missing Michelle Benjamin

Michelle Lynn Benjamin - The Charley Project

...View 4 additional sources

Victim Details

created

Oct 23, 2009

Case Added

Apr 06, 2020

firstname

Michelle

lastname

Benjamin

Current Age

52

Age at Disappearance

35

Height

67 inches

Weight

130 lbs

ethnicity

White / Caucasian

gender

Female

Last Seen

Jun 22, 2007

City

Saint Marys

State

Pennsylvania

County

Elk County

Zip Code

15857

Tribal Land

No

vehicles

234

Agency ID

7578

Agency Name

Pennsylvania State Police

Agency City

Punxsutawney

Agency State

Pennsylvania

Agency County

Jefferson County

Agency Zip Code

15767

Agency Contact

Randy Powell

Contact Job Title

Trooper

Agency Address

485 North Findley Street, Pennsylvania

Agency Phone

8149380535

Agency Jurisdiction

County

Agency Type

Law Enforcement

Agency Case #

C06-0978733

Agency Report Date

2007-07-24

Primary Agency

Pennsylvania State Police

Hair Color

Blond/Strawberry

Left Eye Color

Blue

Right Eye Color

Blue

Last Updated

11/07/2025

Area Last Seen:

Michelle Benjamin
Missing

Case Description

Links to Additional Sources (6)

Victim Details

Forum Posts (1)

Other Missing Cases from Pennsylvania