Steven Aiello Missing Person Case

Apr 16, 2011

Dec 22, 2020

Steven

Aiello

53

23

68 inches

190 lbs

White / Caucasian

Male

In the late summer of 1995, a 23-year-old man from the Bronx, Steven Aiello, was on the verge of a new beginning. He was set to start a new job as a bricklayer and had his whole life ahead of him. Steven, also known to friends and family as Steve or Stevie, was last seen on either September 11 or September 15, 1995, in the Bronx, New York; some sources specifically mention Bronxdale Avenue as his last known location. At the time of his disappearance, he was described as a white male, standing 5'8" and weighing 190 pounds, with brown hair and brown eyes. He had a distinctive scar on his forehead and a tattoo on his right forearm that said "Stevie" accompanied by red panther paws. After that September day, Steven Aiello was never seen or heard from again. The circumstances surrounding Steven's disappearance are complex and point toward a sinister conclusion. While he was preparing for a legitimate trade, authorities believe his connections to organized crime may have led to his vanishing. Prior to his disappearance, Steven had acted as an alibi witness in a significant criminal case involving the Gambino and Genovese crime families. His testimony was instrumental in the acquittal of a man charged with the murder of a Genovese crime figure's son, a killing allegedly ordered by the Gambinos. This involvement placed him in a precarious and dangerous position, caught between two powerful and rivalrous mafia families. Investigators strongly suspect that foul play was involved in Steven Aiello's disappearance. The prevailing theory is that his vanishing was a direct consequence of his testimony. Authorities believe that one of the crime families may have retaliated against him due to suspected perjury on the witness stand. Adding a layer of tragedy to the case, Steven's father was a high-ranking official in the New York Police Department, running the Bureau of Criminal Investigation at the very time his son went missing. The case provides an overview of a young man on the cusp of a new life who vanished without a trace. Despite the passage of time, the investigation into what happened to Steven Aiello remains open, a painful unsolved mystery for his family, with the strong suspicion that he was silenced for his role in a dangerous underworld conflict.

Sep 11, 1995

Bronx

New York

Bronx County

21482

New York City Police Department - Missing Persons Squad

New York

New York

New York County

10039

2770 Frederick Douglass Boulevard, New York

2126947781

Local

Law Enforcement

KNMP07734

New York City Police Department - Missing Persons Squad

Brown

Brown

Brown

08/19/2026