Jason Lee Shifflett, known to his loved ones as “Jay,” was a devoted son, father, brother, and friend. The 31-year-old White / Caucasian man was born on May 8, 1984, and was cherished by everyone who came into his life. His family was his world, and his son, Justin, was his number one priority. Jay loved his son with all his heart and soul and was immensely proud to be his father. Remembered as a good-hearted man with a funny personality, Jay would brighten the lives of those he met. His generosity was legendary among his friends and family; he would give his last penny to help someone, even if it meant going without. He loved being on his boat, spending time on the water with his son, family, and friends.
Tragedy struck in the pre-dawn hours of Thursday, September 3, 2015. Just before 1:00 a.m., Jason was inside his trailer home in the 1500 block of Carlton Avenue in Charlottesville, Virginia, when he heard a knock at his door.
When he answered, three masked men forced their way inside. An eyewitness reported that the intruders demanded money. During the confrontation, one of the men shot Jason at close range. The three assailants then fled, taking nothing from the home. They were seen possibly leaving the area in a white SUV of an unknown make or model. Jason Lee Shifflett died at the scene. His killing was the first homicide in Charlottesville that year.
The community was left in shock and grief. On the evening of his death, more than 100 people gathered outside his home for a candlelight vigil to mourn the sudden loss. In the days that followed, a friend, tattoo artist Ira Morris, organized a fundraiser, donating a portion of the proceeds from memorial tattoos to Jason's family to help with funeral expenses. A funeral service was held on September 12, 2015, and he was interred at Holly Memorial Gardens.
The Charlottesville Police Department immediately launched a homicide investigation. Over the years, detectives have interviewed numerous people and followed many leads, but the case has been hampered by a lack of forensic evidence and forthcoming witnesses. In 2016, a detective on the case noted that while they had persons of interest, there was no hard evidence to make an arrest. Police have repeatedly stated their belief that there are people in the community who have the information needed to solve the crime and have urged them to come forward for the sake of Jason's family.
For years, Jason’s mother, Robin Bryant, was a fierce and public advocate for justice for her son. On what would have been his 33rd birthday, she stood before the Charlottesville Police Department and made a plea for answers. "I will never, ever, ever give up,” she said, addressing his killers through the media. “I don’t care if I’m 98 years old, you will be caught because you took away something precious from me, from his son, and from his brothers and family, and we’re not gonna stand by and let you get by with this.” Sadly, Robin Bryant passed away in March 2023, without ever seeing justice for Jason.
As of September 2021, the investigation into Jason Shifflett's murder remains active and unsolved. The Charlottesville Police Department continues to seek information from the public. A combined reward of up to $11,000 is available for information that leads to an arrest, with $10,000 offered by the City of Charlottesville and up to $1,000 from Crime Stoppers. Authorities ask anyone with information regarding this case to contact the Charlottesville Police Department at (434) 970-3280 or Crime Stoppers at (434) 977-4000.