In the small town of Gore, Oklahoma, the life of 29-year-old Sarah Diane Diamond, a white female, came to a tragic and violent end on November 28, 2016. What was initially believed to be a suicide was later revealed to be a brutal murder that would remain a cold case for several years, leaving a community in suspense and a family without answers. Sarah was discovered deceased in her home, and for a long time, the true circumstances of her death were shrouded in mystery.
The silence in
the case was finally broken in October 2022, when investigators arrested a married couple from Gore, Colton Younger Perry and Misty Dawn Perry, both 33 at the time. The pair were charged with first-degree murder, bringing a shocking turn to the long-unsolved case. The arrests followed a renewed investigation that uncovered a sinister plot and a confession that painted a chilling picture of Sarah's final moments.
According to court records that came to light after the arrests, Misty Perry confessed to being the one who shot Sarah in the head in her bedroom. However, her confession came with a disturbing claim of coercion. Misty alleged that her husband, Colton, had handed her a. 45 caliber revolver and forced her to commit the murder by threatening to kill her and her family if she refused to comply.
Further details from the investigation supported Misty's account of being coerced. A witness, Jeremiah Bell, told investigators that on the night of the murder, he had seen Colton Perry waving a gun and heard him admit to killing Sarah. This, combined with Misty's confession, provided the evidence needed to move forward with charges against the couple. Following their arrests, Colton and Misty Perry were held without bond at the Muskogee County/City Detention Facility, awaiting justice for the death of Sarah Diane Diamond.
