Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
298 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 6 sources
Michael Allen Boyle, a 22-year-old resident of Reno, Nevada, lost his life to gun violence on July 3, 2011. The incident involved his friend, Matthew Mahaffey, who pulled the trigger and ended Boyle's life.

Matthew Mahaffey, the suspect in this case, was a young Iraq War veteran and a close friend of the victim. The circumstances surrounding the shooting are tragic and complex. Mahaffey's actions on that day remain largely unexplained, even to this date. As stated by Boyle's mother, Joni Spade, 'Only Matthew Mahaffey knows why he pulled the trigger back on July 3rd of 2011, killing his good friend Michael Boyle.'

The aftermath of the shooting was marked by significant distress for Boyle's family. The news of his death was disseminated through social media before the police could inform them, adding to their pain and frustration. Spade recalled, 'It was through friends that he had done this on Facebook. That's how I was notified.'

Initially, there was a delay in Mahaffey's arrest and charging. It was not until six months after the shooting that any action was taken. This delay was highlighted by a News 4 Fact Finder Investigation, which prompted authorities to re-examine the case. Following this investigation, Mahaffey was arrested less than a month after the report aired.

Mahaffey's arrest led to a legal process that ultimately resulted in a plea deal. In February 2013, Mahaffey accepted a plea bargain that was likely to allow him to avoid prison time. This outcome was deeply disappointing for Boyle's family, who felt that justice had not been served. Spade expressed her dissatisfaction, stating, 'I believe he should have done time. And jail time is not what I consider time. He murdered my son.'

The plea deal was agreed upon by the Washoe County District Attorney's office, with the family reportedly consenting to the terms. However, this agreement did little to alleviate the family's grief and sense of injustice. Mahaffey's attorney acknowledged the tragedy of the situation, noting, 'We have a young man who is dead. We have another young man who caused his death. It's a tragedy all the way around.'

In summary, Michael Allen Boyle's death was a result of a shooting by his friend Matthew Mahaffey, an Iraq War veteran, on July 3, 2011, in Reno, Nevada. The case was marked by delays in Mahaffey's arrest and a plea deal that allowed him to avoid prison time, causing significant distress for Boyle's family. Despite the legal resolution, the family continues to feel that justice was not fully served.