Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 2 sources
Frederick House Barner was a man who had built a life of service, first to the railroads that connected the country and then to the community he called home. A 48-year-old White/Caucasian male, he was born on July 20, 1860, in Susquehanna Township, Pennsylvania. He eventually made his way west to Pueblo, Colorado, where he married Edith C. Sell on October 17, 1888. For years, he worked as a conductor for the Santa Fe and Denver and Rio Grande Railroads, a respected and steady profession. In 1908, seeking a new way to serve, he joined the Pueblo Police Department. He was known for his bravery and a fearless dedication to his duty. At home, he was a husband and a father to three sons: 17-year-old Roy, 15-year-old Joseph, and 11-year-old Carl.

In the early spring of 1909, a series of burglaries along Grand Avenue had set Pueblo residents on edge. The police were on high alert, working to apprehend the individuals responsible for the string of break-ins. On the evening of Sunday, March 21, Officer Barner was on patrol when he confronted and arrested two men near 10th and Grand whom he suspected were connected to the crimes. With his suspects in custody, Barner began escorting them toward the police call box located at the corner of 10th and North Main streets. His intention was to use the box to summon a patrol wagon to transport the men to the station.

As Officer Barner reached the call box and began to open it, the routine arrest took a devastating turn. One of the suspects suddenly stepped back, creating a fatal distance between himself and the officer. In that moment, the man drew a handgun and fired a single shot. The bullet struck Barner directly in the chest, piercing his heart. The two assailants immediately fled, running eastbound on 10th Street and disappearing into the darkness of the vacant lots near the Grand Hotel. A detective, identified as Detective Gray, heard the gunshot from nearby and rushed to the scene. He arrived within minutes to find Officer Barner deceased on the street.

The murder of a police officer prompted a massive response from the Pueblo Police Department. Dozens of officers were called in to conduct an extensive search of the area, but the killers had vanished without a trace. In the days that followed, investigators rounded up several potential suspects, but all were eventually released due to a lack of evidence. The prevailing theory was that Officer Barner had apprehended two members of the gang responsible for the Grand Avenue burglaries. The investigation soon focused on a man named Felix Martinez, who was arrested and charged based on witness descriptions and a hat that was found at the crime scene.

However, as the case against Martinez was built, a critical piece of evidence emerged that cast serious doubt on his involvement. At the time of his arrest, Martinez was carrying a .38 caliber revolver. The forensic evidence from Officer Barner’s body showed that he had been killed by a .41 caliber bullet. This significant discrepancy weakened the prosecution's case. To further clarify the matter, Las Animas County Undersheriff Kreegar traveled to Pueblo to interview Martinez. After their meeting, the undersheriff concluded that Martinez was likely innocent of the murder. Based on this assessment and the conflicting evidence, Felix Martinez was released.

In the end, no one was ever convicted for the murder of Officer Frederick H. Barner. His death sent a shockwave through Pueblo, and the community gathered to mourn its fallen hero. His funeral was held on March 26 at St. Mark’s English Lutheran Church on Pitkin Street. Nearly 1,000 people attended the service, a testament to the high esteem in which he was held. The funeral procession was a solemn and grand affair, coordinated by the Elks Lodge #90 of Pueblo and joined by members of the police department, the Masons, and the Order of Railway Conductors. Officer Barner was laid to rest in the Elks Rest section of Roselawn Cemetery.

The case remains unsolved, a painful and unresolved chapter in the city’s history. Frederick Barner was survived by his wife, his three sons, his parents, Joseph and Sarah Barner, who lived in South Dakota, and six siblings. His death in the line of duty stands as a stark reminder of the dangers law enforcement officers face. More than a century later, the question of who killed the dedicated patrolman at the corner of 10th and Main remains unanswered, and his killers were never brought to justice.