Coy N. Smith was a man who dedicated his life to his family and to public service. A resident of Citronelle, Alabama, he was a devoted husband to his wife, Barbara, a loving father to his son and daughter, and a doting grandfather to his four grandchildren. For 28 years, he served as an enforcement officer with the Alabama Public Service Commission, rising to the rank of Lieutenant. At 61 years old, the white male officer was a respected veteran known for his commitment to his work, his love for fishing and hunting, and his active membership in the First Baptist Church of Citronelle. His life was one of quiet dedication, deeply rooted in his community and the family he cherished.
On the morning of Tuesday, June 28, 1994, Lt. Smith was on patrol in Montgomery, Alabama, performing his routine duties. Around 10:30 a.m., he initiated a traffic stop on a 1994 Chevrolet pickup truck with a Florida license plate near the intersection of the new Interstate 85 interchange and Perry Hill Road. As he was radioing in the license plate number to a dispatcher, the driver of the truck, Andrew Joseph Lagreca, opened fire. Lt. Smith was struck once in the head, a fatal wound that ended his nearly three-decade career in law enforcement. The gunman immediately fled the scene, sparking a massive manhunt.
The investigation, led by the Montgomery Police Department, quickly revealed that this was no random act of violence. The shooter, Andrew Lagreca, was already a wanted fugitive. He was the primary suspect in the murders of Greenville, Alabama, police officer Gary Heath, who was killed on June 25, and Pearl River County, Mississippi, Sheriff's Deputy Heathcock, who was slain on June 27. Lagreca was in the midst of a multi-state crime spree, and Lt. Smith had tragically become his third law enforcement victim in just four days. The news sent a shockwave through the law enforcement community across the South.
The manhunt for Lagreca intensified, involving local, state, and federal agencies. The search came to a dramatic and violent end later that same day in a wooded area in nearby Lowndes County. As authorities, including federal agents, closed in on his position, Andrew Joseph Lagreca took his own life, ending the desperate search. With the death of the sole suspect, the investigation into the murder of Lt. Coy N. Smith was officially closed.
In the wake of the tragedy, those who knew Coy Smith remembered a man of integrity and quiet strength. His funeral was held at the First Baptist Church of Citronelle, the place where he had long been a faithful member. He was laid to rest at Pine Crest Cemetery in Citronelle, leaving behind a legacy of service and a family devastated by their sudden, violent loss. His dedication was later immortalized in his community, with a highway in the area being named W. Coy Smith Highway in his honor.
The case of Lieutenant Coy N. Smith is considered solved, as the primary and only suspect died on the same day as the murder in June 1994. While justice in a courtroom was preempted by the suspect's suicide, the facts of the case were never in doubt. The loss of Lt. Smith, along with the other two officers murdered by the same man, serves as a stark reminder of the dangers faced by law enforcement officers and the profound impact their sacrifice has on their families and communities.