On a Thursday in late autumn, the 21st of November, 2019, a welfare check at a residence in the 4100 block of Rosa Parks Avenue in Montgomery, Alabama, led to a grim discovery. Inside the home, authorities found the body of 33-year-old Paul Charles Joyner Jr., a Black male. The nature of the scene immediately suggested that his death was not from natural causes, prompting a thorough investigation by the Montgomery Police Department.
As detectives processed the scene and collected evidence, their initial suspicions of foul play were confirmed. The case, which began as a standard death investigation, was quickly reclassified as a homicide. It was determined that Joyner had been a victim of gun violence. The focus of the investigation then shifted to finding the person or persons responsible for his death.
The breakthrough in the case came less than a week later. On November 27, 2019, Montgomery police announced the arrest of 30-year-old Jeremyah Smith of Montgomery. The investigation had led detectives to identify Smith as the primary suspect in Joyner's death. Authorities stated that the motive behind the fatal shooting was robbery. Following his arrest, Jeremyah Smith was charged with capital murder and was taken to the Montgomery County Detention Facility to await further legal proceedings.