Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 5 sources
On a summer night in Boston, a house party turned into a scene of fatal violence that would set in motion a chain of events stretching over years, leaving two families grieving and a murder investigation still open. Twenty-year-old Kern Cayemite, a young Black man, was at a gathering at 990 River Street in the Hyde Park neighborhood on July 25, 2004, when gunfire erupted. Kern was struck in the chest and pronounced deceased. The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner later ruled his death a homicide.

A second man at the party, John Lubin, was also shot, sustaining wounds to his leg and back, but he survived the attack. In the immediate aftermath, the Boston Police Department launched a homicide investigation into Kern’s death. However, despite their efforts, no arrests were made, and the case grew cold. For three years, there were no public developments, and the question of who shot Kern Cayemite and why remained unanswered. The silence was tragically broken by another act of violence that was directly linked to that night.

On July 4, 2007, John Lubin, the man who had survived the shooting that killed Kern, was fatally shot at a party in Randolph, Massachusetts. The investigation into Lubin’s death soon uncovered a motive rooted in the events of 2004. Prosecutors alleged that Lubin was killed in an act of retribution by relatives of Kern Cayemite who believed he was somehow responsible for Kern's death. This belief, whether based on rumor or other information, festered for three years before culminating in a second killing.

The subsequent legal proceedings brought some clarity to the tragic saga. Kern’s cousin, Jean-Marie Thebaud, who was a teenager at the time of Lubin's death, was charged with the murder. Prosecutors stated the killing was done to gain status within a Hyde Park-based gang known as the "Westies" and as direct retaliation for Kern's death. In October 2009, Thebaud pleaded guilty to second-degree murder for killing John Lubin and was sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole. Charges against three other individuals, including Thebaud's brother, were eventually dropped by prosecutors.

While the murder of John Lubin was legally resolved, the original crime that set everything in motion remains officially unsolved. The investigation into the homicide of Kern Cayemite is still in the hands of the Boston Police Department. In July 2007, a department spokesman, Patrol Officer Eddy Crispin, confirmed that no charges had ever been filed in the case.

As of October 2024, Kern Cayemite's name is still listed on the Boston Police Department's roster of unsolved homicides. The case that sparked a years-long story of violence and retribution has never been closed. While one family saw a conviction in a related killing, the person or people responsible for the murder of Kern Cayemite have never been brought to justice. The Boston Police Homicide Unit continues to seek information from the public and urges anyone with knowledge of the case to come forward.