Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 1 source
In the busy Port Norfolk neighborhood of Dorchester, a section of Boston shaped by its industrial shoreline and hardworking residents, Herman Nick had built his livelihood. At 64 years old, the male business owner ran a scrap metal company, a trade that deals in the discarded and overlooked, finding value where others might not. His firm was located at 140 Granite Avenue, a busy thoroughfare running parallel to the Neponset River, an area familiar with the sounds of commerce and labor. But on a spring day in 1974, the ordinary rhythm of the workday was shattered by violence, leaving behind a mystery that has endured for decades.

On Wednesday, May 22, 1974, police officers from the Boston Police Department were called to the scrap metal yard on Granite Avenue. Inside his place of business, they found Herman Nick. He was pronounced deceased at the scene. Initially, investigators considered the possibility that his death was the result of an accidental fall, a plausible scenario in an industrial setting. However, the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner soon uncovered a more sinister cause. An autopsy revealed that Mr. Nick had not fallen; he had been killed by a single gunshot wound to the head. The manner of death was officially ruled a homicide, making him the 52nd murder victim in the city of Boston that year.

The investigation into Herman Nick’s murder was launched by the Boston Police Department’s Homicide Unit. In 1974, Boston was a city grappling with deep social and political turmoil, most notably the contentious court-ordered school desegregation and busing crisis that began that fall, which consumed public attention and strained law enforcement resources. Detectives in that era worked without the advanced forensic tools, such as widespread DNA analysis and digital databases, that are now fundamental to solving crimes. They would have relied on traditional methods: interviewing potential witnesses, searching for a motive in the victim's personal and professional life, and chasing down leads that all too often grew cold.

In the case of Herman Nick, the trail of evidence and information seems to have faded quickly. Publicly available information has not revealed a motive for the killing. Robbery is a common assumption in crimes at a place of business, but police did not release details confirming or denying if anything was taken. There were no publicly named suspects or persons of interest. Without witnesses stepping forward and with limited forensic technology, investigators were left with unanswered questions. Who would have targeted the owner of a scrap metal business, and why? Was it a dispute, a robbery gone wrong, or something else entirely?

Decades have passed since Herman Nick was killed. The industrial landscape of Dorchester has changed, and the city of Boston has transformed around it. Yet, his case remains officially unsolved, one of dozens of cold cases from that year still on the books of the Boston Police Department. For every unsolved murder, there is a void—a network of family, friends, and community members left without answers or closure. The specific memories of who Herman Nick was—his personality, his family life, his passions—have faded from the public record, eclipsed by the brutal and unresolved nature of his death.

As of today, the investigation into the homicide of Herman Nick is inactive but remains open. The Boston Police Department’s Unsolved Homicide Unit periodically reviews cold cases, hoping that a new witness, a forgotten memory, or a breakthrough in technology might provide the missing piece to the puzzle. The department encourages anyone with information, no matter how insignificant it may seem, to come forward. The passage of time can change allegiances and ease fears, and it is possible that someone, somewhere, still holds the key to bringing a resolution to this decades-old case.

Links to Additional Sources (1)

See any mistakes? Let us know!