Who Killed Andrae J. Davis? Andrae J. Davis, a 31-year-old African-American father, was a man deeply devoted to his family. He lived in Albuquerque, New Mexico, with his fiancée and their young children, creating a life centered around them. On the evening of August 17, 2011, Andrae and his family had enjoyed a simple, pleasant outing at a local park before returning to their home at the Eagle Nest Condominiums on Vail Street SE. They could not have known that the night would take a horrific and irreversible turn.
Shortly after they got home, a loud argument erupted among a group of men just outside their front door. Concerned by the commotion, Andrae peered through the peephole to see what was happening. He was not involved in the dispute and did not know the men, but he stood as a silent witness to the escalating conflict. As he watched, one of the men pulled out a gun and fired. The bullet was not meant for him; it was aimed at someone in the fight.
But the shot missed its intended target, tore through the wood of Andrae’s front door, and struck him directly in the heart. He collapsed in front of his fiancée and children, a blameless victim of a stray bullet in his own home.
The Albuquerque Police Department responded to the chaotic scene, but the shooter had already vanished. In the immediate aftermath, investigators learned that the conflict may have been tied to drug activity within the complex. The investigation was hampered from the start as key individuals disappeared. Police informed Andrae’s family that one person of interest had reportedly escaped from the University of New Mexico Hospital and fled to Mexico. It was believed that at least two other individuals connected to the shooting also fled the country, their identities never publicly released. With no arrests made and the primary suspects gone, the criminal investigation stalled, leaving Andrae's murder to become a cold case.
While the criminal case languished, Andrae’s family sought another form of accountability. They filed a lawsuit against the Eagle’s Nest Condominium Association and its property management company, Roger Cox & Associates. The family’s attorney argued that the management was negligent, failing to perform required background checks and screenings on tenants. This failure, they contended, allowed a known drug dealer, believed to be involved in the fatal altercation, to reside in the complex. The lawsuit also cited previous reports of trouble at the property that had not been adequately addressed.
In March 2015, a jury in Santa Fe agreed with the family’s argument, finding the condominium association and management company responsible for the circumstances that led to Andrae's death. They awarded the family a $12 million judgment for their profound loss. The property management company stated its disagreement with the verdict and its intention to appeal. While the civil verdict provided a measure of financial justice, it could not fill the void left by Andrae’s absence or answer the family’s most pressing questions.
Years have passed, but the pain for Andrae Davis's loved ones remains. The person who fired the shot that ended his life has never been captured or held criminally responsible. The case remains one of Albuquerque’s unsolved homicides, a lasting tragedy for a family that lost a devoted partner and father to a senseless act of violence that found him on the other side of his own front door.
The investigation into the murder of Andrae Davis is still open. Authorities continue to ask for the public’s help in bringing his killer to justice. Anyone with information about the shooting that occurred on August 17, 2011, at the Eagle Nest Condominiums is urged to contact Albuquerque Crime Stoppers at 505-843-STOP.