Logan Cutchall, a 22-year-old White/Caucasian male from York, Pennsylvania, was shot late on June 18, 2022, after what authorities described as a family argument that followed a wedding. Police said the shooting happened around 11 p.m. in the 600 block of Linden Avenue in York. When officers arrived, they found Logan wounded inside the home; investigators said he had been shot multiple times in the kitchen.
He was taken to York Hospital, where he died just after midnight, making the source-reported date of death June 19, 2022, even though the shooting occurred on June 18.
The confrontation involved Logan’s older brother, Nathaniel Cutchall, who was 24 at the time. According to police and court documents reported by local media, the brothers and others had attended a wedding earlier that day. On the way home, an argument began in the car. Authorities said Logan pulled out a gun during the dispute, and Nathaniel, who was seated in the back, managed to disarm him and unload the weapon. After that, Logan reportedly drove away, leaving Nathaniel and others on the roadside, and the stranded group later got another ride back to the Linden Avenue home.
Once they arrived back at the house, the conflict did not end. Police said Logan was accused of pointing guns at people inside the home and making threats to shoot or kill multiple people. Court documents described witnesses hearing gunshots after Logan and Nathaniel became involved in a physical struggle in the kitchen. When witnesses went in, they reportedly saw Nathaniel holding a gun while Logan lay on the floor with gunshot wounds. Nathaniel then fled the scene, but police later found him on June 19 along the 900 block of Wayne Avenue. Authorities said he had a gunshot wound to his right foot.
Nathaniel Cutchall was arrested and initially charged with criminal homicide in connection with Logan’s death. A judge denied bail after the arrest, and a preliminary hearing was scheduled. Early reporting described the case as a homicide investigation, with police still piecing together what had sparked the violence and noting that those involved may have been under the influence of alcohol.
The case later changed sharply. York County prosecutors dropped the criminal homicide charge against Nathaniel on August 4, 2022, after reviewing the facts, evidence, and applicable law. The York County District Attorney’s Office said it could not meet the burden of proving the case beyond a reasonable doubt because Nathaniel was determined to have acted in self-defense. Court records reported by FOX43 indicated that Nathaniel was released from prison a few days after the charge was dropped. No conviction or sentencing was reported, because the homicide charge was dismissed rather than carried through to trial or punishment.
