Timothy Koker, a 52-year-old male of Caucasian ethnicity from Nelsonville, Ohio, tragically passed away on December 23, 2015. He was the well-respected owner of the Mine Tavern, a popular local bar in Nelsonville. Timothy was known for his active involvement in the community, participating in various civic organizations such as the Nelsonville Elks Lodge, the Logan Moose Lodge, the Nelsonville VFW, and the Masonic Lodge. He was also passionate about outdoor activities like hunting and riding four-wheelers.
On the night of his death, Timothy was involved in a confrontation with Taylor Allen Mills, a 22-year-old male, at the Mine Tavern. According to reports, Mills was causing a disturbance and was asked to leave the bar by Timothy. After leaving and returning to the bar, Mills allegedly threw an object at a window, prompting Timothy to ask him to leave again. It was during this second confrontation that Mills fired shots, hitting Timothy. Despite attempts at CPR by the police, Timothy was pronounced dead at the hospital.
Taylor Allen Mills was arrested and charged with murder. During his court appearance, the bond was set at $1 million due to the nature of the crime. Mills was later found guilty of involuntary manslaughter and other related charges. He received a 27-and-a-half-year prison sentence, with the requirement that he serve at least 22 years before being eligible for early release.
The investigation into Timothy Koker's death involved multiple law enforcement agencies, including the Nelsonville Police Department, the Ohio Bureau of Investigation, and the Athens County Prosecutor's Office. The case drew significant attention due to the circumstances of the shooting and the community's respect for Timothy.
Timothy Koker's death left a void in the Nelsonville community, as he was a beloved figure who contributed significantly to local civic life and was remembered fondly by those who knew him.
