Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 9 sources
Jackie Summers Skelton was a kind, gentle soul with a warm smile that could light up a room. At 66 years old, the White/Caucasian woman was a beloved oncology nurse at Vidant Hospital in Tarboro, North Carolina, known for her compassion and for treating her patients and coworkers like family. Originally from Alabama, Jackie and her husband, Gary Skelton, had made their home in the small community of Leggett, where Gary served as the mayor. The couple, who were active members of Englewood Baptist Church in Rocky Mount, had three sons and six grandchildren. Jackie had recently spoken of retiring soon to spend more time rocking her grandbabies. Friends and family remembered her as a genuine, caring person who loved her Lord and her family deeply.

The life Jackie and Gary built together came to a violent end on September 5, 2018. After they were last seen having dinner with another couple, they returned to their home on North Carolina Highway 33. The following day, September 6, Jackie’s concerned coworkers requested a welfare check when she failed to arrive for her nursing shift. Deputies from the Edgecombe County Sheriff’s Office responded to the couple’s rural residence and made a devastating discovery. Jackie and Gary Skelton were found inside their home, both having been shot to death. The news sent shockwaves through the quiet town and beyond, leaving friends and loved ones heartbroken over the senseless loss of two people described as the "epitome of good people."

The Edgecombe County Sheriff’s Office launched an immediate and intensive investigation. Within hours, authorities had suspects in custody, bringing a small measure of relief to a community on edge. The investigation led to the arrests of three individuals. Keith Earl Williams, then 25, and Mitchell Brinson, then 18, both from the nearby city of Tarboro, were each charged with first-degree murder. A third person, 30-year-old Dakeithia Nesha Andrews of Rocky Mount, was later arrested and charged with conspiracy to commit robbery with a dangerous weapon.

The legal process for the three defendants concluded over the next four years, bringing a final resolution to the case. In October 2020, Keith Earl Williams pleaded guilty to two counts of first-degree murder. A judge sentenced him to two consecutive life sentences in prison without the possibility of parole.

The remaining two defendants accepted plea deals in December 2022 in Edgecombe County Superior Court. Mitchell Brinson pleaded guilty to two counts of accessory after the fact to first-degree murder. He was sentenced to serve between 73 and 100 months in state prison. Dakeithia Andrews pleaded guilty to one count of accessory before the fact to armed robbery. She received a suspended prison sentence of 64 to 89 months and was placed on 24 months of supervised probation.

In the wake of the tragedy, the community mourned the loss of a couple who had given so much. Jackie was remembered not just as a dedicated nurse, but as a friend who was always there for others, lifting spirits and showing grace in everything she did. A celebration of life for both Jackie and Gary was held at their church, Englewood Baptist, on September 11, 2018, before their bodies were returned to their native Alabama for burial. Her pastor of 15 years recalled them as outgoing, friendly people who loved to entertain and had moved to the country to get away from the "hustle and bustle." As of December 2022, the criminal case is considered closed, with all three individuals involved in the deaths of Jackie and Gary Skelton having been convicted and sentenced.