Patrolman Patrick Fogarty, aged 41 years, was a dedicated officer of the Chicago Police Department's 10th Precinct – Hyde Park. On the night of July 1, 1911, Fogarty was off-duty and spending time with his nephew, Michael Hannon. They had enjoyed a night out at a picture show and visited several saloons with friends. Fogarty returned to his nephew's boarding house to ensure he got home safely.
Early the next morning, at around 2:15 a.m., Fogarty was leaving his nephew's residence when
he was approached by three men. The assailants attacked him, and during the struggle, one of them, identified as John Gay, gained control of Fogarty's weapon. The gun discharged, striking Fogarty in the groin. He was rushed to Grace Hospital but succumbed to his injuries later that day at 3:00 p.m.
The investigation into Fogarty's death revealed that the shooting was likely an act of revenge. Witnesses, though inebriated, provided statements indicating that one of the attackers mentioned Fogarty's attempt to arrest them. Bernard Friedman, a witness, recalled hearing one of the assailants say, 'You are the fellow who tried to arrest us.' The attackers fled the scene, leaving Fogarty mortally wounded.
Following the investigation, John Gay was arrested and charged with manslaughter. On January 13, 1912, he was convicted and sentenced to an indeterminate term in Joliet Penitentiary. The case highlighted the dangers faced by law enforcement officers, even when off-duty, and the risks associated with their commitment to public safety.
Fogarty's death was a tragic event that underscored the bravery and sacrifice of police officers. His legacy is honored on various memorial walls, including the Illinois Police Officers Memorial Wall and the National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial Wall. His story serves as a reminder of the perils officers face and the importance of their service to the community.
