Frank R. Panebianco

On a cool autumn evening in Port Jefferson Station, New York, what began as a night out for Frank R. Panebianco and his girlfriend ended in a sudden and violent tragedy. On November 2, 2014, the 28-year-old male was fatally shot in the parking lot of the L.I. Pour House Bar & Grill. Frank, an employee at TD Bank and the eldest of four brothers, had been dating Jessica Kasten for a few months.

That Sunday night, as Frank and Jessica were leaving the restaurant with friends, they were confr ...