Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Share what you know: tips, sources, questions and theories about this case. Be respectful; abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

2 discussions · 2 posts

Kathy Lynn Hemphill, 51, disappeared from her Tulsa home in October 2017 after an argument with her…

FD FD

Kathy Lynn Hemphill, 51, disappeared from her Tulsa home in October 2017 after an argument with her common-law husband outside their residence in the 5900 block of west 4th Place. Both Kathy and her white 2005 Chrysler PT Cruiser were gone after that dispute. Family members say it was out of character for her to leave behind her dog and all her personal belongings.

Her husband gave varying explanations to friends and family and told police she had left for California, a claim investigators considered not credible; he was identified as a person of interest but not charged. In the same month Kathy vanished, a man named John David Lee II was seen driving her PT Cruiser, was later arrested on unrelated auto theft charges, and the vehicle was recovered. Lee is also a person of interest in a separate 2014 disappearance.

No charges have been filed and the investigation has gone cold. Does anyone have information about Kathy, her whereabouts in October 2017, or who last saw her and her PT Cruiser?

18 Reply Report

Kathy Jo Hemphill, 51, was last seen by family in October 2017 at her home in the 5900 block of west 4th…

AF AF

Kathy Jo Hemphill, 51, was last seen by family in October 2017 at her home in the 5900 block of west 4th Place in Tulsa. Neighbors reported hearing a heated argument that day between Kathy and her common-law husband. Her white 2005 Chrysler PT Cruiser was missing when she vanished; she also left behind her dog and all of her personal belongings.

Kathy is described as having green eyes, medium-length brown hair often worn with feathered bangs, several tattoos including a rose on her left breast and a bird on her upper right back, and scars on her nose and back. Her family says there was a history of domestic violence in the relationship. The husband has been named a person of interest, but no charges were filed due to insufficient evidence.

In February 2018 a man identified as John David Lee II was seen driving Kathy’s recovered PT Cruiser, was arrested on unrelated auto theft charges, and has been publicly named a person of interest in this case; he is also linked as a person of interest in the 2014 disappearance of Richard Horn. The Tulsa County Sheriff’s Office lists the investigation as open. If anyone knew Kathy, her routines, or saw the PT Cruiser after October 2017, can you share what you remember?

18 Reply Report