Andrew Memmelaar Missing Person Case

Aug 31, 2011

May 23, 2023

Andrew

Memmelaar

67

17

71 inches

150 lbs

White / Caucasian

Male

In the autumn of 1975, a 17-year-old male named Andrew Memmelaar embarked on a journey that would become a decades-long mystery. On October 25, he departed from Lehigh, Kansas, with the intention of visiting relatives in the small town of Jeffersonville, New York. Andrew, a young man with red hair and blue eyes, never reached his destination, and his loved ones have not heard from him since that day. The details surrounding his travel plans and the exact circumstances of his disappearance remain scarce, leaving a void of information for both his family and the authorities investigating his case. At the time of his disappearance, he was described as being approximately 5'11" to 6'1" tall and weighing around 150 pounds. Distinctive physical characteristics were noted in Andrew's case file, offering potential clues to his identity. He had a one-inch scar on his lower left arm and another scar near his right armpit from the removal of a cyst. Additionally, a previously broken collarbone on his right side had not healed properly. These identifying marks, while significant, have not yet led to a breakthrough in the case. The Sullivan County Sheriff's Office in New York is the primary agency investigating his disappearance, a task they have continued for many years. The case has been documented by multiple missing persons organizations in the hope that public awareness might generate new leads. The narrative of Andrew Memmelaar's disappearance is one of enduring uncertainty. A young man setting out to connect with family seemingly vanished without a trace, leaving a trail of unanswered questions. The lack of detailed information about his mode of transport or his exact route has complicated the investigation from the outset. Over the years, law enforcement has kept his case open, a testament to their commitment to resolving the mystery of his whereabouts. The passage of time has not diminished the hope of finding answers, and his case serves as a poignant reminder of the lasting impact of a person's unexplained absence on their family and community. The investigation into what happened to Andrew on his journey from Kansas to New York remains an active and unresolved matter.

Oct 25, 1975

Jeffersonville

New York

Sullivan County

10697

Sullivan County Sheriff's Office

Monticello

New York

Sullivan County

12701

Anthony Skow

Detective

58 Old Route 17, New York

8457947100

County

Law Enforcement

44-76

2023-05-23

Sullivan County Sheriff's Office

Red/Auburn

Blue

Blue

09/04/2026