Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
298 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on the NamUs case record (MP35388) and 3 other sources
In what should have been a joyous occasion turned into a devastating tragedy on the island of Kauai. Carl Wayne Rotstein, known to his friends and family as Wayne, was in Kauai County, Hawaii, to be the best man at his friend's wedding. The 49-year-old was staying on a six-acre property with a group of friends, including the bride and groom, Christina Michelle MacNees and Daniel Arroyo, and his business partner, Aurora Solveig Fehring Dingwall, her husband Alan Gareth Dingwall, and their young son. The group was gathered in anticipation of the wedding and the upcoming second birthday of the Dingwalls' son.

The morning of the planned wedding ceremony brought with it a catastrophe that no one could have foreseen. After an extended period of heavy rainfall, the Kaloko Dam breached, unleashing an immense and destructive wall of water upon the community below. The property where Rotstein and his friends were staying was directly in the path of the deluge. The sheer force of the water swept away everyone present, including Rotstein, the engaged couple, and the entire Dingwall family. In the aftermath, a search and rescue operation was launched, but the scale of the devastation was immense. While the bodies of some of the victims were recovered, Carl Wayne Rotstein was not among them.

The investigation following the dam's collapse revealed a history of neglect and a disregard for safety regulations. It was discovered that the dam, which was over a century old, had not been inspected for many years, despite state laws requiring regular safety checks. The owner of the dam was ultimately held responsible for the disaster, facing legal consequences for his role in the tragic loss of life. For the families and friends of those who vanished, the legal proceedings offered little solace. Carl Wayne Rotstein, along with several others, remains missing, presumed to have been swept away by the floodwaters. The case serves as a heartbreaking reminder of the profound and lasting impact of this preventable disaster, leaving a permanent void in the lives of those who knew and loved the vibrant man who had traveled to Hawaii to celebrate a union of love, only to be taken by a force of nature exacerbated by human negligence.

Last Seen: Mar 13, 2006