Sarah Stern Missing from Neptune City, New Jersey age 19

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!

Sarah Stern, a 19-year-old from Neptune City, New Jersey, went missing on December 2, 2016. Her car was discovered abandoned on the Route 35 bridge in Belmar, leading investigators initially to suspect suicide. However, this theory shifted when authorities uncovered a more sinister truth.

Stern had been murdered by her longtime friend Liam McAtasney. McAtasney, along with his accomplice Preston Taylor, planned to rob Stern of money she had recently inherited from her grandmother. On the ...Read More
Last Seen: Dec 02, 2016

Links to Additional Sources (9)

See any mistakes? Let us know!

Sarah Stern murder: Killer McAtasney's conviction upheld

...View 8 additional sources

Victim Details

created

Dec 07, 2016

Case Added

Nov 07, 2019

firstname

Sarah

lastname

Stern

Current Age

27

Age at Disappearance

19

Height

66 inches

Weight

130 lbs

ethnicity

White / Caucasian

gender

Female

Last Seen

Dec 02, 2016

City

Neptune City

State

New Jersey

County

Monmouth County

Zip Code

07753

Agency ID

30320

Agency Name

Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office

Agency City

Freehold

Agency State

New Jersey

Agency County

Monmouth County

Agency Zip Code

07728

Agency Contact

Brian Weisbrot

Contact Job Title

Detective Sergeant

Agency Address

132 Jerseyville Avenue, New Jersey

Agency Phone

7324317160

Agency Jurisdiction

County

Agency Type

Law Enforcement

Agency Website

https://mcponj.org/

Agency Case #

HM16-00178

Primary Agency

Monmouth County Prosecutor's Office

Hair Color

Brown

Left Eye Color

Hazel

Right Eye Color

Hazel

Last Updated

09/29/2024

Area Last Seen:

Sarah Stern
Missing

Case Description

Links to Additional Sources (9)

Victim Details

Forum Posts (1)

Other Missing Cases from New Jersey