Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 6 sources
Patricia Ann Gonyea was a bright and popular 17-year-old with dreams of moving to California for college to study accounting. A senior at South High Community School in Worcester, Massachusetts, she was a good student who earned As and Bs and a talented athlete who enjoyed track and horseback riding. To her friends, who knew her as Patty Ann, she was kindhearted, always smiling, and full of life. She was one of six children and worked part-time as a waitress at Abdow’s Big Boy Restaurant. Her family remembered her as having a great sense of humor and always being on the go.

On the evening of October 22, 1984, Patricia had the night off from work and spent it playing cards at her boyfriend's house. She called her mother around 9:40 p.m. to say she would be home a little later. Though she had planned to get a ride, she ended up taking a bus to get home. Her boyfriend walked her to the stop to make sure she got on safely. The bus driver later recalled chatting with her before she got off on Main Street, across from Clark University, at about 11:15 p.m. She was only a few blocks from her family’s home on Southgate Street, a walk that should have taken just a few minutes. A witness reported seeing a man walking about 50 feet behind her, but Patricia never made it home.

The next morning, when her mother realized she was missing, the family began a frantic search. They found her purse on nearby railroad tracks and alerted the police. A short time later, officers made a devastating discovery in a six-foot-deep window well of a factory complex near Grand Street, just two blocks from her home. Patricia’s naked body was found covered with cardboard and discarded lumber. Her clothes were located in a nearby alley. An autopsy determined she had been sexually assaulted and had died from massive blunt force trauma to the head, including a skull fracture, around midnight. Investigators also found a wire wrapped around her neck.

The Worcester Police Department immediately launched a homicide investigation. Detectives believed the killer was someone familiar with the industrial area. One detective who grew up in the city recalled how the crime changed the community, making people feel it was no longer safe to walk around and that they had to start locking their doors. Over the decades, investigators have continued to pursue leads. In 2007, biological evidence from the scene was sent for forensic analysis. While the testing did not yield a complete DNA profile of a suspect, it did identify several alleles, or DNA subfragments, that did not belong to Patricia or her boyfriend. The identity of the person or people they belong to remains unknown.

Forty years later, Patricia’s family and friends continue to ache for answers. Her mother, Kathleen Vivlamore, passed away in 2010 without ever knowing who killed her daughter. Her younger brother, Frank Gonyea, has spoken of the anger he carried for years and the certainty that his sister would have done amazing things with her life. Her childhood friends, including a group who called themselves "the three Patties and Lisa," have kept her memory alive with a solemn and loving ritual. Every year on October 22, no matter the weather, they gather at the end of Grand Street near where her body was found.

At these annual vigils, they share memories, laugh, cry, and express their frustration that the case remains unsolved. They release purple balloons and light paper sky lanterns, watching them float into the twilight. They play her favorite song, "Purple Rain" by Prince, and say a prayer. The friends, now in their late 50s, have brought their own children to the memorials over the years, a poignant reminder of the life Patricia never had the chance to live. They have vowed to continue gathering every year until the day they die or the day her killer is found. A GoFundMe was also started to fund a memorial bench in her name at a local field.

As of October 2024, the murder of Patricia Gonyea remains an open and active investigation with the Worcester Police Department's Unresolved Homicide Unit. No arrests have ever been made. Detectives believe that relationships change over time and that someone who has stayed silent for decades may now be willing to come forward with the information needed to finally bring justice to Patricia and her loved ones. Anyone with information is asked to call the Worcester Police Department’s detective bureau at 508-799-8651 or send an anonymous text to 274637, starting the message with TIPWPD.