Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 Cases Solved. Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Case Description

Any updates on this case? Let us know!
Summary based on 4 sources
In the late autumn of 1967, Sarah Cox was a 21-year-old woman building a life for herself in Worcester, Massachusetts. By day, she worked as a secretary for the Massachusetts Defenders, a public defender group. By night, she was a dedicated student, taking classes at Clark University. Her mother described her as responsible and considerate, someone who would always call if she was going to be even 15 minutes late. Her disappearance was entirely out of character, leaving her family baffled and terrified.

On the evening of Wednesday, November 29, 1967, Sarah's routine was tragically broken. She typically left her job downtown and took a bus to her evening classes at Clark University. Around 10 p.m., she was reportedly seen boarding a public bus on campus, presumably for the two-mile journey toward her apartment on Highland Street. The initial police theory, based on the bus driver's account, was that Sarah got off the bus at Lincoln Square to walk the final nine blocks home. The driver said she was alone, carrying books and a bag. When she never arrived, her roommate reported her missing.

A citywide search ended in heartbreak four days later. On Sunday, December 3, 1967, Sarah’s body was discovered in a wooded area off Granite Street, more than four miles from where she was thought to have gotten off the bus. Her naked body had been left in a frozen ditch. An autopsy confirmed she had been strangled to death. Several of her belongings were missing, including a distinctive black Chesterfield coat with a velvet collar, her black shoes, and an Agogo watch.

The Worcester Police Department immediately launched an intensive homicide investigation, assigning more than two dozen officers to the case. Detectives questioned around 300 people in the weeks that followed, desperately searching for answers. The investigation took a sharp turn when a Clark University student came forward with information that contradicted the initial timeline. This new lead convinced police that Sarah might have never boarded the bus at all on the night she vanished, turning the entire investigation on its head and leaving a critical gap in her last known movements.

The murder of Sarah Cox was one of three unsolved strangulations of women that occurred within a 12-month period in the Worcester area, creating a climate of fear in the community. Just over six months earlier, in April 1967, 55-year-old Teresa Borbone was found strangled in her Millbury home. A few months after Sarah’s death, in April 1968, the body of 17-year-old Phyllis Ann Morrissette was found strangled in a local pond. The similarities in the cases were striking, but no definitive link was ever publicly established by law enforcement.

For more than five decades, Sarah’s murder has remained without an arrest. The case is an active, unsolved homicide with the Worcester Police Department. In December 2022, her story was the focus of the Season 2 premiere of the "Unsolved: Worcester" podcast, which reviewed the details of the cold case in the hopes of generating new leads. As of an April 2024 update, the investigation is still open.

No one has ever been charged with the murder of Sarah Cox, and the case continues to haunt the city. The Worcester Police Department urges anyone with information, no matter how insignificant it may seem, to come forward. Tips can be sent anonymously by texting 274637 TIPWPD plus your message, or through the department's website. The Unresolved Homicide Unit can also be reached directly at 508-799-8688.