Nancy Lee Eagleson, a 14-year-old girl from Paulding, Ohio, was tragically murdered on November 13, 1960. Nancy and her 5-year-old sister, Sheryl, had just finished a day at the movies and were walking home when a man in a car offered them a ride. When Nancy declined, the man forced her into the car and drove away, leaving Sheryl behind. Nancy's body was found the next day in a wooded area known as "Nancy's Woods," where she had been shot twice in the head and sexually assaulted.
The
case remained unsolved for decades, with various suspects and theories emerging over the years. One notable suspect was Clair "Bud" Paulus, a deputy for the Paulding County Sheriff's Office, who was accused of similar crimes by another woman, Cindy Geyer Keith. Despite numerous investigations and renewed efforts, including the creation of composite sketches of the suspect by Nancy's sister, Sheryl, the case has yet to be resolved.
The Paulding County Sheriff's Office has confirmed that new evidence has been uncovered, but it has not led to a definitive conclusion. The case continues to be a cold case, with authorities hopeful that new information or tips from the public might eventually lead to justice for Nancy Eagleson.
The tragic death of Nancy Lee Eagleson remains a haunting mystery in the small town of Paulding, Ohio, and her story continues to evoke sympathy and a desire for closure among those who knew her and the community at large.
