On Christmas Eve of 2011, a day typically filled with warmth and celebration, a grim discovery was made in a quiet corner of Cleveland, Ohio. The body of James See Jr., a 25-year-old Black man, was found on the second floor of a desolate, abandoned house at the intersection of Hulda Avenue and East 110th Street. The holiday peace was shattered by the reality of a life cut short by violence.
The discovery was made at approximately 9:05 p.m. in the city's Mount Pleasant neighborhood. An investigation by the Cleveland Division of Police determined that James had been killed by a single gunshot to the head. The circumstances leading up to his death remain shrouded in mystery, leaving his loved ones with unanswered questions and the heavy burden of grief during a time meant for family and joy. The setting of the crime, a vacant and neglected property, added a layer of coldness to an already brutal act, offering few clues for investigators to follow.
In the years since James's death, the investigation has remained open but has yielded no arrests. The case has grown cold, a term that does little to capture the ongoing pain for a family still waiting for justice. Detectives with the Cleveland Police have pursued what leads they could, but without a clear motive or suspect, the path to resolving the case has been fraught with difficulty. The silence surrounding the crime has been a persistent source of anguish for those who knew and loved James.
The lack of progress has left the community and James’s family in a state of perpetual uncertainty. With no one held accountable for the murder, the sense of closure that a conviction might bring remains cruelly out of reach. The case rests heavily on the hope that someone, somewhere, holds the key piece of information that could break the silence and reignite the investigation.
To encourage anyone with knowledge of the crime to come forward, Crime Stoppers of Cuyahoga County has offered a cash reward of up to $2,500. This reward is for information that leads directly to the arrest and indictment of the individual or individuals responsible for the murder of James See Jr. The offer of anonymity is a crucial component, ensuring that potential witnesses can share what they know without fear of reprisal.
More than a decade has passed since James See Jr. was killed, but the quest for justice has not ended. His case is a somber reminder of the violence that can strike unexpectedly and the lasting impact it has on families and communities. As of November 2026, his murder remains unsolved. Authorities continue to urge anyone with any information, no matter how insignificant it may seem, to contact Crime Stoppers.