Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Share what you know: tips, sources, questions and theories about this case. Be respectful; abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

2 discussions · 2 posts

Karol Marlene Sullens was 18 when she vanished from Galena, Kansas, on the night of August 31, 1991.

EI EI

Karol Marlene Sullens was 18 when she vanished from Galena, Kansas, on the night of August 31, 1991. She was working as an exotic dancer at the Valley of The Dolls nightclub on 7th Street and was seen during a break in the club’s parking lot talking to an unidentified man near a dark-colored pickup truck with a camper shell. She left behind her purse and other personal items at the bar and was never seen again.

Karol was described as a white female, blonde hair, green eyes, 5 feet 3 inches tall, about 100 pounds, with a scar from an appendectomy and pierced ears. Authorities long suspected she died from a drug overdose the night she disappeared and that those who supplied the drugs concealed her body. In 2001 Donald D. Kidwell was charged with causing her death through reckless actions and another man, Donald E. Davis, was charged with aggravated battery and cooperated. In 2002 Kidwell pleaded guilty to battery and obstruction, received 18 months in prison and a $1,500 fine, and admitted responsibility for her death while denying sexual assault or intent. Karol’s remains have never been found and her family continues to seek answers.

Does anyone have information about Karol’s last known movements or about the dark pickup truck seen that night?

18 Reply Report

Karol Marlene Sullens was 18 when she vanished after a shift at the Valley of the Dolls nightclub in Galena,…

OI OI

Karol Marlene Sullens was 18 when she vanished after a shift at the Valley of the Dolls nightclub in Galena, Kansas. She was last seen the night of August 31, 1991, talking with an unidentified man beside a dark-colored pickup truck with a camper shell during a break. Her purse and personal effects were left behind inside the club and she has not been seen since.

Authorities at first suspected a drug overdose and thought people involved with drugs may have hidden her body. In 2001 two men, Donald Kidwell and Donald Davis, were charged in connection with the case. Davis told investigators that Karol had passed out in their vehicle and that Kidwell carried her into a wooded area, returning without her. Searches in Kansas and Oklahoma, including abandoned mine shafts, turned up no remains. Kidwell later pleaded guilty to battery and obstruction of official duty but denied intending to cause Karol’s death.

Her remains have not been recovered and the disappearance remains unresolved. If anyone knew Karol, worked at the Valley of the Dolls, or saw a dark-colored pickup with a camper shell near the club on August 31, 1991, please come forward with information.

18 Reply Report