Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
307 cases solved Advancing justice for missing persons, unsolved homicides, unidentified and unclaimed remains.

Share what you know: tips, sources, questions and theories about this case. Be respectful; abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

2 discussions · 2 posts

Valerie Lorraine Cuccia, 20, vanished after a night out in Brooklyn on May 4, 1974.

NC NC

Valerie Lorraine Cuccia, 20, vanished after a night out in Brooklyn on May 4, 1974. She and a friend hitchhiked from P.S. 211 Park in Canarsie to the Banana Fish nightclub in Bay Ridge, where they became separated. At about 9:00 p.m. the friend saw Valerie get into a blue metallic-finished car with two unidentified white men who had Massachusetts license plates; some accounts say she may have been forced into the vehicle. She never returned home.

Valerie was a City College of New York student and a musician who left two guitars at home. She lived with her parents and younger sister on East 96th Street and was described by family as full of life and not someone who dated often. She was last seen wearing a plaid coat with a fur collar, a striped polo, camel-colored pants, and black studded boots; she has a scar on her left calf. Her parents pursued many leads over the years, and her two brothers continue to seek answers. The family has submitted DNA to a state database; the case remains unsolved.

Does anyone remember seeing a blue metallic-finished car with Massachusetts plates in Bay Ridge on May 4, 1974, or have information about Banana Fish nightclub patrons that night?

18 Reply Report

Valarie Lorraine Cuccia, a 20-year-old City College of New York student who lived with her parents in…

NE NE

Valarie Lorraine Cuccia, a 20-year-old City College of New York student who lived with her parents in Canarsie, Brooklyn, disappeared on May 4, 1974. That evening she and a friend hitchhiked from PS 211 Park to the Banana Fish nightclub at 96th Street and 3rd Avenue. The friends separated inside; Valarie’s companion later saw her talking to two unidentified white men described as hard looking.

Around 9:00 p.m. Valarie was last seen getting into a blue car with Massachusetts license plates. It is believed she may have been forced into the vehicle. She left her guitars and personal items at home, and authorities think she may have been taken to Massachusetts, but no trace of her has been found since that night.

Her family, including her brothers, has continued to seek answers. If anyone knew Valarie, saw her that night, or has information about a blue car with Massachusetts plates in Brooklyn on May 4, 1974, please come forward.

18 Reply Report