Crime Solvers Central
Crime Solvers Central
300+ cases resolved with our help Helping bring answers to families of the missing, murdered, unidentified and unclaimed.

Share what you know: tips, sources, questions and theories about this case. Be respectful; abuse of these forums will not be tolerated.

2 discussions · 2 posts

Arlene Gehrke, 58, was shot in the head and killed inside her small one-room church in Buckeye, Iowa, on the…

IK IK

Arlene Gehrke, 58, was shot in the head and killed inside her small one-room church in Buckeye, Iowa, on the evening of Sunday, September 5, 1976. She had gone to practice the organ for upcoming Labor Day services when an intruder entered the building and fatally shot her.

Investigators from the Iowa Bureau of Criminal Investigation processed the scene. Arlene’s car had been ransacked, which led to early speculation about robbery as a motive, but the pastor’s wife said little of value was normally kept in the church. Detectives spent two days searching for clues but developed no significant leads. No suspects were publicly identified and no arrests were made; the case remains an unsolved homicide in Hardin County.

Does anyone have memories from Buckeye in 1976 or information that could help bring new attention to this case?

0 Reply Report

Arlene Gehrke, 58, a church organist in the Buckeye, Iowa, area, was robbed and shot in the back of the head…

YU YU

Arlene Gehrke, 58, a church organist in the Buckeye, Iowa, area, was robbed and shot in the back of the head on September 4, 1976. The execution-style killing initially appeared to be an isolated act of violence in rural Iowa, but investigators later found it fit a wider pattern.

Authorities eventually connected Gehrke’s death to Allen Leroy Anderson, a fugitive whose summer–fall 1976 travels involved stolen vehicles, credit-card fraud, robberies and multiple murders across several states. Most victims linked to Anderson were shot in the back of the head with a .22-caliber weapon; investigators recovered a .22-caliber revolver from Anderson after his October 28, 1976, arrest. Anderson was charged with first-degree murder in Iowa and was publicly identified as Gehrke’s killer, though surviving accounts differ about the final disposition of the Iowa prosecution.

Gehrke’s case became one piece of a nationwide investigation that used stolen vehicles and credit-card records to trace Anderson’s movements. Did anyone in the Buckeye area remember Arlene Gehrke or see suspicious activity around September 4, 1976?

0 Reply Report